While many customers praised the crabs and seafood dishes, there were several complaints about overcooked and dry items, particularly ribs and some seafood.
Service
The service received consistent positive feedback, with many customers highlighting the attentiveness and friendliness of the staff.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere was generally well-received, described as cozy and lively, although some noted it could be noisy.
Value
Customers appreciated the reasonable prices for the seafood, especially during all-you-can-eat specials, but some felt certain items were overpriced.
JH
Jeffrie Harden
3 days ago
3.0
Food was decent smaller portions than whats advertised, felt rushed the servers didn't really give us time to decide what we wanted..then felt like they were pushing us out the door. Nice place will we return? Probly Not.
CS
Callee Stauffer
6 days ago
5.0
Very nice atmosphere. The food seemed a bit high priced until it arrived. It was a large serving and excellent taste. We just stopped on our way through but if we lived closer we'd definitely be eating here again!
JC
Janice Cole
Jan 2, 2026
5.0
I drove 2 hours there and picked up a half bushel of crabs, and I must say they were the BEST!! Will definetly be back. When I went inside everyone was very friendly and very nice atmosphere
JB
Joe Bennett
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
Food was excellent. Had to make a reservation which made it easy to get in. The parking lot is a bit small for the popularity of the establishment but overall first time experience excellent.
TC
taylor clear
Dec 21, 2025
5.0
Have been coming here for years for my family’s Merlin Steamed Crabs addiction, hon.
Never had a bad bushel yet.
I tried pestering them into serving the ultimate bar food, char-grilled oysters, but so far, no dice.
Can’t go wrong with a half bushel on Memorial Day and another on Labor Day.
(Maybe one on July 4th, too).
Frequently Asked Questions About Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn
What are the regular dining hours at Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn?
Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn is open for dining from Wednesday to Saturday, 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM, and on Sunday from 12:00 PM to 6:00 PM. It is closed on Monday and Tuesday.
When is Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn available for takeout and delivery services?
Takeout and delivery services are available from Wednesday to Saturday, 12:00 PM to 8:20 PM, and on Sunday from 12:00 PM to 5:20 PM. The restaurant is closed for these services on Monday and Tuesday.
Does Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn offer in-store pickup for orders?
Yes, Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn offers in-store pickup as one of its order fulfillment options.
What types of cuisine and dining experience can I expect at Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn?
The restaurant offers a variety of cuisines including seafood, crab, oysters, American dishes, steak, and desserts. It also features a bar and grill atmosphere suitable for families.
Where is Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn located?
It is located at 7536 Millstone Rd, Hancock, MD 21750, USA.
How can I view the menu or place an order online for Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn?
You can view the menu and place orders online by visiting https://jimmyjoyslogcabin.com/menu.
What is the price range of Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn?
The price range at Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn is indicated as moderate (TWO).
What nearby establishments can I visit along with Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn?
Nearby you can find The Log Cabin steakhouse, Hancock Church of God, and Little Pool Campground; these offer dining, religious services, and camping opportunities respectively, enhancing your visit experience.
Is The Log Cabin steakhouse close to Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn, and can I visit both when dining or socializing?
Yes, The Log Cabin steakhouse is nearby and offers an additional dining option if you want to explore more steakhouse experiences in the Hancock area.
Can visitors to Little Pool Campground conveniently dine at Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn?
Absolutely, guests at Little Pool Campground can conveniently visit Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn for meals, as it is located nearby and provides a suitable dining choice after outdoor activities.