Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• DP

  Dhyey Patel

  Apr 1, 2026
  1.0
  I go as walk in and ask for menu the lady behind the counter she tells me order online we don’t have menus and attitude is not good
• RS

  Rick Harper Sr

  Mar 14, 2026
  5.0
  Pizzas are always great. Sides are also good. In over 15 years of ordering from the Papa John's in Edgewood, they have never messed up an order. Delivery is always on time and the drivers are always great 👍
• ED

  Eugenia Dyson

  Feb 28, 2026
  1.0
  SHUT THIS PLACE DOWN worst disturb and trifling experience ever no gloves I walked in this place I asked the guy for a half and half pizza he went to make the food he took to long over 30 minutes I saw him pick a piece of food up and did not wash his hands and another dude was eating on the job his hands were dirty under his finger nails touching people food another worker came in from delivering food he was digging in his ears wiping it on his shirt and then touching others people food all three guys were white(not a racial threat) dirty looking don't care about people order and can catch multiple bacterial attacks from these three men I fear for my life safety issues I don't even want to give it no stars because it is nothing I can possibly like,eat,or smile about this food
• GB

  Gavin Bryant

  Jan 3, 2026
  1.0
  Made an online order, the driver couldn't find my address and then lied about trying to call. Never got my money back or the pizza. Sent an email about it with no response.
• LF

  Lena Frances

  Dec 28, 2025
  1.0
  Something has clearly gone wrong over at this Papa John’s, because my last three orders have all been bad. Tonight I ordered the new menu item, the Grand Papa Pizza. Which, as far as I can tell, is just an extra-large pizza. The order was here in about 40 minutes and all of my neighbors know my order was here because the delivery driver was blasting music!!! Anyways, just like my last few orders, there was barely any tomato sauce on it. At this point, I’m not ordering pizza — I’m ordering a very flat loaf of bread with aspirations. Honestly, I paid for what amounts to a large order of cheesesticks. And we already ordered cheesesticks. Somehow the cheesesticks were better than the pizza. That feels unbalanced. So we called — calmly — because we hadn’t complained the last three times this exact thing happened. And the manager tells us, very confidently, that the Grand Papa pizza comes with light sauce by default… because it’s extra large. And they don’t add more sauce to match the size of the pizza. Now… slap me and call me Gumby, because I did not see that coming. You’re telling me the bigger the pizza gets… the less pizza it becomes? Show me anywhere in the advertising where it says, “Hey, just so you know, this pizza is mostly vibes.” Because I must’ve missed that part. There was a time when this location would fix a problem. They’d remake it. Apologize. Act like they cared. Now it’s just, “Yeah, that’s how it is,” and you’re left holding a warm piece of disappointment. So yeah… we’re done ordering here. Not angrily. But by default….

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza