Fitzwilly's Restaurant

Reviews

• TC

  T C

  Jun 9, 2025
  5.0
  The food here is absolutely incredible! It's a clean restaurant, with a historical tinge to it's appearance. The staff was attentive to everyone at all times. I didn't see one dissatisfied diner. I ordered the Steak tips with wild mushrooms and rice pilaf. The steak was cooked exactly as I wanted. The wild mushrooms were pan seared in some kind of wine. Point being, they were some of the best tasting mushrooms I've ever had in my entire life. According to their menu, they locally source wild mushrooms and asparagus, so those veggies are fresh as can be. The only caveat with this restaurant is the parking. To get there, you'll need to go around the back of the restaurant (row of buildings on the main street), take a right at the first light after passing Fitzwillys, then take your first right into a kind of alleyway. Drive up a little bit and you'll see paid parking options. I dined there Sunday, so the parking lot was free. Parking lot was a bit filled up. So if you go any other day than Sunday, you'll have to pay for parking via their license plate kiosk. If you go on Friday night or Saturday, you may not find parking available. It gets really busy in that downtown square area. Other than that, it's a good location, within walking distance to other shops near by if you want to window shop.
• BG

  Brooke G

  Jun 9, 2025
  3.0
  The atmosphere is great here. A lot of tavern style drinks and food fare. Some of the sandwiches are great but so many of the other things we've tried have been poorly executed, bland tasting and unfortunately more disappointing than not. This visit, soup was cold and watery for a chowder, onions undercooked for potato skins and barely put together/filled. Pasta was bland. Nachos were decent however, but the chicken on it reminded me of canned chicken. Not sure if I'll be back despite having a few decent sandwiches in the past.
• AJ

  Amanda Jerry

  Jun 6, 2025
  5.0
  Our team had a fabulous celebration at Fitzwilly's after working three very long, tiring days at the Fair Grounds. The food and drink were downright delicious, and the atmosphere was charming, cozy, and convivial! From the moment she brought waters over and introduced herself, we all adored our server Amy. She was very thoughtful, cheerful, and easy to talk to and laugh with. We appreciated her accommodating us so late into the evening—she made us feel right at home! Shout out to Ron behind the bar, and staff member Kevin too—the whole Fitzwilly's team works together to deliver a top-notch customer experience. We will certainly be back on our next visit to the area.
• RF

  Robert Finn

  Jun 2, 2025
  5.0
  Excellent food and beer selection. Service was terrific and that are very dog friendly.

Frequently Asked Questions About Fitzwilly's Restaurant