ES
Erik Starkey
Nov 2, 2025
Disappointed Regulars After Years of Great Visits
My father, my wife, and I went to Si Señor in Hammond two nights ago. We’ve eaten here for 2–3 years now and always considered it one of the best Mexican spots in town. The food has always been great, and our server that night, John, started off excellent — greeted us quickly, polite, and professional.
But the issue came when my dad ordered a beef burrito, meat and cheese only — no lettuce, no avocado, nothing extra. The server suggested a beef wrap instead, and we went with his recommendation, assuming it was the same thing. What came out was full of spinach, avocado, and other ingredients my dad specifically said he didn’t want.
When we politely pointed it out, the server immediately said they couldn’t take it off the bill because “that’s what we ordered.” That’s not right — we ordered based on his suggestion after clearly stating what my dad wanted multiple times. It was a simple mistake that could’ve been handled better, but instead we got told “no” without hesitation.
For three people, our bill came out to $96, and we always tip 20% because we’ve been loyal customers for years. But after this, I honestly don’t see us coming back. Very disappointing experience for a place we’ve always supported.