Business Details
About
Pizza RestaurantBuffet RestaurantArcadeVideo ArcadeFamily Style RestaurantChildren's Party ServiceEvent VenueChicken Wings RestaurantTake Out RestaurantRestaurant Delivery Service
Since 1969, we've been committed to creating unforgettable moments for all of our guests and having the best pizza in town!
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Drive-throughAvailable
- BreakfastNot available
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.2
1,595 reviews
5 stars
920
4 stars
346
3 stars
170
2 stars
63
1 star
96
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Many customers reported a decline in food quality, with issues such as cold pizza, undercooked items, and limited buffet selections.
Cleanliness
Numerous reviews highlighted concerns about the cleanliness of the restaurant, including dirty tables and unsanitary food handling practices.
Service
While some customers praised the friendly and accommodating staff, others noted inconsistent service and a lack of attention to clearing plates.
Atmosphere
Several reviews mentioned the need for renovations and improvements in the dining environment, citing issues like heat and a cramped layout.
Value
Customers generally felt that the buffet offered good value for money, though some expressed disappointment in the overall experience compared to past visits.
- DHDoug Hammond3 days ago3.0Don’t waste money on the ultimate pepperoni pizza, it’s the same as a regular pepperoni. Well actually perhaps less pepperoni.
- AHAmanda HunttNov 8, 20253.0I loved going to the place when I was a child. I know there under new ownership, but they didn't have hardly anything on the buffet just felt different
- LWLegend WarrenOct 28, 20252.0My husband and I haven’t been to this location in a couple years but tonight we decided to give it another shot. The food was just okay, I would say the salad bar was the best thing I ate when I was there. The ranch was pretty good. BUT i work in the food industry and what did me in was seeing someone make a pizza with no gloves and putting cheese on it and then eating the cheese and then continue making the pizza. I did not see a single worker wear gloves and I seen three workers. The restaurant itself was not very sanitary at all.
- LPLana PardonOct 26, 20255.0The very best Mr Gattis! The place is always very clean. Plenty of food selections on the bar. Savanna and her crew replace food quickly. Food is always hot. Salad selections start out with cold, crisp lettuce. You definitely get your money's worth here.
- NDNatalie DavisOct 16, 20251.0Gattis has been my favorite pizza place for YEARS!! They now have a new owner and I will not be back any time soon. The quality of food dropped drastically. Pizza was undercooked, pepperoni pizza only had maybe 15 pepperonis on the entire pizza. Cinnamon sticks were undercooked. The buffet remained fairly empty for the majority of the time we were there, it seemed as if they were more focused on to go orders. There is no more crushed red pepper or Parmesan on the table you have to put it on your pizza over by the salad bar. Overall i was HIGHLY disappointed in this new change. And listening to other customers sitting at tables around me, they were left unsatisfied as well. They will be losing customers.
Frequently Asked Questions About Mr Gatti's Pizza
Where is Mr. Gatti's Pizza in Shepherdsville located?
Mr. Gatti's Pizza is located at 162 Joe B. Hall Ave, Shepherdsville, KY 40165, US.
What are the operating hours of Mr. Gatti's Pizza in Shepherdsville?
Mr. Gatti's Pizza is open Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and on Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
What services does Mr. Gatti's Pizza offer in Shepherdsville?
Mr. Gatti's Pizza offers parties, carryout, salad bar, pizza buffet, large group accommodations, meeting space, and family fun.
Does Mr. Gatti's Pizza in Shepherdsville offer delivery or pickup options?
Yes, Mr. Gatti's Pizza in Shepherdsville offers in-store pickup service.
Is Mr. Gatti's Pizza suitable for children's parties and family fun?
Yes, Mr. Gatti's Pizza features kids parties, games, an arcade, and welcomes families with a children's menu and family fun activities.
Does Mr. Gatti's Pizza offer vegetarian and salad bar options?
Yes, Mr. Gatti's Pizza serves vegetarian food and has a salad bar available.
Are there apps available to order from Mr. Gatti's Pizza in Shepherdsville?
Yes, you can order using their Android app on Google Play or the iOS app from the App Store.
What nearby places can I visit around Mr. Gatti's Pizza in Shepherdsville?
Nearby you can visit Shepherdsville Family Health Clinic, Dairy Queen for ice cream, and the Shepherdsville Farmer’s Market for fresh produce.
Are there other pizza restaurants near Mr. Gatti's Pizza in Shepherdsville?
Yes, nearby pizza restaurants include Gatti's Pizza, Fazoli's, and Little Caesars Pizza.
What accommodations and travel services are near Mr. Gatti's Pizza in Shepherdsville?
Nearby accommodations include Motel 6 Shepherdsville- Ky and Spark by Hilton Shepherdsville Louisville South. For travel needs, there's Marathon Gas and Five Star Food Mart convenience store.