Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• JJ

  Jocko Johnson

  Nov 9, 2025
  5.0
  Good
• LS

  Lauren Stump

  Nov 1, 2025
  1.0
  We ordered pizza for delivery last night, which was Halloween night and we live in college hill so we left a hefty tip and expected them to be super busy. They used DoorDash to deliver the pizza, which is totally understandable, especially on busy evenings like Halloween. What is not understandable is the DoorDash delivery driver being able to deliver multiple other orders ahead of yours in areas nowhere near you and getting your food delivered cold and extremely late (it was a scheduled delivery time and was over 30 minutes late). If we would have known that would be the case, we would have just used DoorDash and paid the extra fee to have it delivered straight to us but that was not an option through papa John’s.
• MM

  Maverick

  Oct 21, 2025
  1.0
  Honestly, I shouldn’t be surprised by what I witnessed today while waiting for my food at Papa John’s. I placed my order as usual — no complaints there, the staff are always friendly whether I call in or order in person. Today, however, I decided to wait inside for my food. I was told it would be about a 20-minute wait — fine, no problem. While I was waiting, I noticed one of the employees (the guy with long hair in a ponytail) boxing pizzas. At first, everything seemed normal until I saw him repeatedly touch his face and then go right back to handling food — grabbing peppers and placing them in boxes — without washing his hands. I also saw him pick up breadsticks with his bare hands after them falling onto the counter a not into the box to put them into the box, and then move on to tagging boxes and making pizzas without ever washing up. Another employee doing the packing was doing the same thing — touching his face, then food — until he noticed me watching. Only then did he start using the red tongs that are clearly meant for the peppers. I understand it’s hot working near the oven, but basic hygiene should never be optional. Use your arm to wipe sweat if needed, or take a quick moment to wash your hands. Watching this happen really made me lose confidence in how the food is handled at this location. If you order food here just don’t sit inside and watch the process.
• JD

  jeff d

  Oct 19, 2025
  1.0
  App says pizza ready in 20 minutes. Arrive at store at 20 minutes. Food was not ready and was told it would be another 20 to 30 minutes. After almost an hour I got the pizza and wings which were lukewarm to cold at best. I won’t be back.
• AF

  Aaron Fisher

  Aug 29, 2025
  1.0
  I’ve never once had a good experience here. I try delivery - cold and takes forever even during dead times. In-store- they always mess it up. I’ve given this store so many chances - and they ALWAYS come up short, and they never seem to care.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza