At Papa Johns Pizza in Tell City, IN, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Tell City pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Tell City or stop by 44 14TH ST for carryout to order the best pizza in Tell City, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Numerous customers reported issues with food quality, including undercooked pizzas, missing toppings, and expired ingredients.
Service Speed
Many reviews highlighted long wait times for orders, both for pickup and delivery, often exceeding the estimated times.
Customer Service
While some customers praised the friendly staff, others reported rude service and poor handling of complaints.
Cleanliness
Several customers noted cleanliness issues within the store, indicating a need for better hygiene practices.
Value for Money
Customers expressed dissatisfaction with the value, citing high prices for subpar food quality.
SM
Sam Moore
6 days ago
1.0
I drove 45 minutes out of my way to get a bacon cheese stick. The general manager tells me that they don’t have bacon cheese sticks, but they have bacon and they have cheese sticks, but he can’t do a bacon cheese stick because that will come out of his pocket. Absolutely the least capable GM of the franchise!
OS
Owen Sitzman
Nov 9, 2025
1.0
Tried calling in to make an order for a pizza and each time I was on hold for more than 5 minutes waiting to speak to someone.
BS
Bridget Swaney
Oct 31, 2025
2.0
I called at 822 pm on October 31 2025 ordered a large pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and a large sausage pizza with extra cheese and was told 30-40 minutes ...got to papa johns at 900 pm and didn't get my order until 930pm ...got home with it and there was no extra cheese on either pizza and it was nasty