Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• PP

  Phoebe

  Sep 13, 2025
  1.0
  What's going on with the online ordering? Papa pairings $6.99 each. Ordered 3 pizzas (no premium toppings) and bread sticks. Total shows over $41. That's not right at all. $7x4= $28. ($5.50 delivery fee +tax around $2.67) that should be $36.17, not $41+. Where's the extra $5 charge coming from? Canceled my order.
• CT

  Chris Timperman

  Jul 18, 2025
  1.0
  I ordered Family Special Delivery from Papa John’s today. An hour after my order was placed, my food arrives in an unmarked vehicle w/ two people in the car arguing. A man with no Papa John’s uniform emerges from an unmarked vehicle and opens the rear door of vehicle. He takes a long time getting my pizza out of the car, as I realized he’s picking my pizza off his floor. He approaches me with pizza’s in hand, no case to hold pizza to keep them warm. Driver hands me the pizza and informs me one of the pizza fell on the floor of his vehicle. I told him I was not accepting the pizzas and to call management and request a refund. The driver informs me that “will take forever and that only one of the pizza’s fell, and they were fine.” I said no sir I’m not eating floor pizza. As I’m speaking his passenger is hollering out the window “what’s taking so long, are you ready yet.” I then asked where was his uniform, or any type of Papa John’s ID. He then informed me he is a DoorDasher. I do not DoorDash due to poor service, constant scams, and sketchy drivers. This is the kind of service you can expect from Papa John’s in Sellersburg, Indiana. The only saving grace to the situation was the Shaun, the manager of that location being kind understanding, and refunding and replacing the order. So buyer beware, Papa John’s now uses Door Dash for all deliveries.
• PG

  Pamela Greenwell

  Jun 23, 2025
  1.0
  I ordered online for delivery my order wasn't delivered when it said it would be so I called the store and they told me that they were short staffed, I asked him to change it from delivery to carry and to take my tip and delivery charge off and I would come pick it up and he said he couldn't take the tip off, finally after arguing I ok forget the tip I will just come get my pizza please change it to carry out. I drove there to get it and my pizza was gone and it had been sent out for delivery anyway. I was so mad I had to argue once again for a refund he only wanted to refund my delivery charge. I got back to my house The pizza was on my porch 2 hrs late and it was terrible.
• MW

  Matthew Wadsack

  Sep 23, 2022
  3.0
  It was ok. They were not wearing gloves as they prepaired food.
• TS

  Trent Spalding

  Aug 19, 2019
  5.0
  What really gave this restaurant five stars for me, was the friendly and welcoming staff. Particularly a worker named Ryley Baker who works the front counter. He has been working for years and deserves a raise. He needs the money to support his 5 kids.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza