Mixed reviews on food quality, with some praising the pizza and salad bar, while others criticized the pasta and sauce.
Service
Service experiences varied; some customers reported friendly and timely service, while others faced long waits and unwelcoming staff.
Atmosphere
The restaurant has a family-friendly atmosphere, but some customers noted cleanliness issues and a lack of warmth from staff.
Value
Customers found the prices reasonable, but some felt the food did not match the cost, particularly regarding the buffet and takeout orders.
Consistency
There are concerns about consistency in food preparation and service, with several customers noting that their experiences varied significantly between visits.
LL
Laura Layden
Nov 2, 2025
5.0
One of my favorite places to eat when I go home to visit family. The pizza and lasagna was delicious.
AT
Alex Traylor
Oct 12, 2025
5.0
The pizza here was soo good and you gotta try the salad bar! The family restaraunt vibes and live music next door sealed the deal. We were just passing through town and stumbled across this small town gem. The service was friendly and timely and we would definitely recommend.
CL
Christopher Lee
Oct 7, 2025
5.0
Mama Rosa's is probably the best restaurant in Salem. We love it. The staff and owners are great people. The food never disappoints. Great atmosphere to.
CT
Cheryl Taylor
Oct 4, 2025
5.0
We happen upon this restaurant coming back from a band competition took us a while to find it, but it was worth the effort. The service was fine. They even had a live band performing, which was pretty cool and the food was excellent so don’t believe those negative reviews that you see on here. It’s good stuff for a good price too.
MB
Marilyn Booker
Oct 3, 2025
1.0
WHERE'S THE SAUCE?
I love mama rosa usually but the last two times I ordered takeout I was very disappointed. I always order spaghetti and these last two times had barely any sauce on it. I couldn't even taste any sauce and had to use some of my own out of my pantry. Please do better MR!!
Mamma Rosa's is located at 201 Arthur St, Salem, IN 47167, USA.
What are Mamma Rosa's opening hours during the week?
Mamma Rosa's is open Tuesday to Thursday from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM. The restaurant is closed on Mondays.
What types of cuisine does Mamma Rosa's offer?
Mamma Rosa's offers Italian cuisine including pizza and pasta, and features a buffet-style dining experience.
What payment methods are accepted at Mamma Rosa's?
Mamma Rosa's accepts American Express, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa payment options.
How can I contact Mamma Rosa's?
You can contact Mamma Rosa's by calling +1 812-883-6296.
Does Mamma Rosa's have a social media presence?
Yes, Mamma Rosa's is on Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/MammaRosasIN.
What nearby establishments can I visit after dining at Mamma Rosa's?
After dining at Mamma Rosa's, you can visit Bill's American Pub for drinks, Dairy Queen Grill and Chill for desserts, or the LibertyX Bitcoin ATM for financial services, all located nearby.
Are there convenient fuel and convenience store options near Mamma Rosa's?
Yes, Circle K and Fast Max Sunoco gas stations and convenience stores are nearby for quick fuel and shopping needs.
Where can I find other dining options near Mamma Rosa's?
Near Mamma Rosa's, you can find other dining options such as SUBWAY for sandwiches, Domino's for pizza and chicken, and McDonald's for fast food.
What services are available near Mamma Rosa's for pet care and beauty?
Nearby, you can find Salem Veterinary Service for pet care and Guy's & Dolls Salon 'A new beginning' for beauty and spa services.