Brand Certified
Papa Johns Pizza
3.3(226 reviews)
Certified by Papa Johns Pizza • Mar 01, 2026
Business Details
3955 Hayley Drive, Newburgh, IN
47630, United States
Certified by Papa Johns Pizza • Mar 01, 2026
(812) 858-7272
Certified by Papa Johns Pizza • Mar 01, 2026
https://locations.papajohns.com/united-states/in/47630/newburgh/3955-hayley-drive?utm_source=gmb&utm_medium=organic
Certified by Papa Johns Pizza • Mar 01, 2026
About
Certified by Papa Johns Pizza • Mar 01, 2026
Pizza RestaurantPapa John's
At Papa Johns Pizza in Newburgh, IN, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Newburgh pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Newburgh or stop by 3955 Hayley Drive for carryout to order the best pizza in Newburgh, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
Location
Certified by Papa Johns Pizza • Mar 01, 2026
Hours
Certified by Papa Johns Pizza • Mar 01, 2026
Reviews
3.3
226 reviews
5 stars
91
4 stars
34
3 stars
25
2 stars
10
1 star
66
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Order Accuracy
Numerous customers reported issues with incorrect orders, including wrong pizza cuts and missing items.
Delivery Issues
Many reviews highlighted long wait times for delivery, with some orders arriving cold or not at all.
Customer Service
Feedback indicated a lack of professionalism and poor customer service, with rude staff and inadequate responses to complaints.
Food Quality
While some customers praised the pizza, many others noted inconsistencies in quality, including undercooked pizzas and insufficient toppings.
Management Concerns
Several reviews pointed to poor management and staffing issues, leading to chaotic service and long wait times.
- MAMarissa ArtisFeb 5, 20261.0The pizza and breadsticks were awful. There were several large bubbles in both pizzas. The sauce and toppings were not spread to the edges, leaving about 1.5in of "crust". We will definitely not be eating here again.
- LWLauryn WatkinsJan 30, 20265.0We decided to get papa john’s tonight and ordered their 6.99 deal for wings and pizza. It was good! Our delivery driver was very nice and respectful to come out into the winter weather and provide good service!
- SWSarah WeigmanJan 4, 20261.0We placed an order and received an email confirmation, and the card was charged. Email said pizza would be here 730 at the latest. I waited until 8pm and called. They pulled up everything, and then said "I dont show a delivery". They said they refunded it. We'll see.
- AWAustin WilesDec 31, 20255.0The guy working is a trooper. He's the only one in here by himself handling all orders. He definitely deserves a raise. (Went in on 12/31 at 11:30)
- ASAngela SaganOct 25, 20251.0Delivered completely wrong order. Told I was going to have to wait another hour for replacement because there's other people ahead of me waiting.. Who have been waiting a long time.. (apparently longer than the order that I should have already had?🤣) I then asked for my money to just be refunded and it still has yet to be refunded! And I went and got my kids food elsewhere that night.
Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza
What are the delivery hours at Papa Johns Pizza in Newburgh, IN?
Delivery service is available Monday through Thursday and Sunday from 10:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and on Friday and Saturday from 10:00 AM to midnight.
Can I order takeout from Papa Johns Pizza in Newburgh, and what are the takeout hours?
Yes, takeout is available daily from 10:00 AM to 11:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and until midnight on Friday and Saturday.
What services does Papa Johns Pizza offer at this location?
They offer delivery, takeout, order ahead, lunch and dinner service, and desserts.
Where is Papa Johns Pizza located in Newburgh, IN?
The restaurant is located at 3955 Hayley Drive, Newburgh, IN 47630, United States.
What products can I order from Papa Johns Pizza in Newburgh?
You can order pizza, wings, desserts, breadsticks, cheesesticks, and beverages.
Does Papa Johns Pizza offer contactless delivery?
Yes, this location provides no-contact delivery for customer safety.
How can I place an order for delivery or carryout at Papa Johns Pizza?
You can order online for delivery or carryout using their official website or mobile apps available on iOS and Android.
Are there any nearby places where I can get tutoring or schooling near Papa Johns Pizza?
Yes, Kumon tutoring center is nearby, making it convenient for families to grab pizza after tutoring sessions.
What beauty and spa services are located near Papa Johns Pizza in Newburgh?
Nearby beauty and spa options include Aubree's Aesthetics, Oasis Massage Studio, Self Care with Tiffany, Brow Haus & Co LLC, Amazing Aimee's Suite Salon, and Hair By Angela, perfect for a relaxing visit before or after enjoying pizza.
What other dining options are near Papa Johns Pizza in Newburgh?
Nearby restaurants include The Rooster's Den for breakfast and brunch and Burger King for fast food, offering variety if you're looking to explore local dining.
Brand Certified Facts from Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza partners directly with Yext to publish this data from the brand's official system of record. Learn more about our data sources
Certified March 01, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website