Numerous customers reported slow service, long wait times for food, and rude interactions with staff.
Food Quality
Many reviews highlighted poor food quality, including cold, overcooked, or incorrect orders.
Management Concerns
Customers expressed dissatisfaction with management's responsiveness and handling of complaints.
Positive Staff Experiences
Some reviews noted positive interactions with individual staff members who provided good service despite overall issues.
JJ
Jackson
1 day ago
1.0
This location is consistently failing on both service and quality. I ordered to-go and waited 20 minutes past the scheduled pickup time. While waiting, I overheard other guests who had been waiting 50 minutes for their food. This seems to be a recurring issue with their kitchen management.
Beyond the wait, the food quality was unacceptable. I am on a strict diet and rely on the nutritional info provided on their website, but what I received was not equivalent. The "naked tenders" were the size of nuggets, a side salad was missing entirely, and the boneless wings were tiny and mostly breading.
While the manager did provide a refund when I called, the repeated lack of reliability and poor food portions are a dealbreaker. Much like the local Casey’s recently did, this location desperately needs a management overhaul to turn the service around. I won’t be returning.
SC
Steve Cooper
Dec 23, 2025
5.0
Nice place to watch my favorite NFL team, even though they lost. My one blazin' wing will keep warm memories alive for days.
SB
Sleeping Beauty
Dec 3, 2025
1.0
There was an issue with my order. I tried to call and speak to a manager, but I was told one was not available. Ii was just relayed information supposedly. I have ordered this meal 3x, all with sauce on the side. Never was an issue until today in which the sauce was NOT on the side. I only wanted to bring it to their attention and get a small refund as some needed to be plain due to allergies. I was told that I was wrong and that I rang it in incorrectly online and there was nothing that they could do. So I asked if they wanted me to come up with my many confirmation and she said yes.
The older lady that I guess isn't a true manager was there. I guess it was short staffed. She wasnt even supposed to be managing. Not a great sign when that's the introduction. But she was nice. She was NOT the girl I spoke with on the phone. The shift lead /kitchen load offered to remake my food but I didn't trust that option after continued rude interaction with the lady on the phone. She still tries to tell me what I ordered wax wrong and try to point out that my kitchen receipt said no dressing and nothing about the sauce on side. Until the lead was like, no look at her phone. And the cashier lady just scoffed and was like I've never seen that before. Its Usually it's the customers fault because they rang it wrong.
How is any of that great customer service? The lead did say she was going to follow up with a manager named Noah to process a refund as she couldn't. I still haven't heard anything. Just crazy to tell a customer that they did something wrong without having the full story.
AP
Amber Plough
Nov 30, 2025
1.0
WARNING: Would give zero starts if I could. We placed an order online, saying that it would be ready at 3:10. The order was 25 MINUTES late being readied. Zero discount, apology or anything. AND the dining room was empty! This is the worst service we have had in years! This restaurant will be out of business soon if things do not change. Awful!
WV
Wally VanSlyke
Nov 11, 2025
5.0
First of all, the service was second to none when we visited last night. They quickly corrected a couple of order mistakes and seemed happy to make it right. The food was hot and the stuffed tater-tots were great. Dining room was clean they have plenty of parking. Very pleasant experience. Their pick 6 - Meal for two is a great deal! Also new is the brown sugar heat sauce for their wings, very tasty.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in New Castle offer?
Buffalo Wild Wings offers award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with a choice of 26 sauces and seasonings.
What are the operating hours of Buffalo Wild Wings in New Castle?
Buffalo Wild Wings is open Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:59 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in New Castle?
It is located at 1715 South Memorial Drive, New Castle, IN 47362, USA.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in New Castle?
You can call them at +1 765-388-2800 for inquiries or reservations.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in New Castle suitable for takeout orders?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings is categorized as a takeout restaurant along with being a sports bar and chicken wings restaurant.
Are there any fitness or gym facilities near Buffalo Wild Wings in New Castle?
Yes, Anytime Fitness, a gym and fitness center, is located nearby where you can work out before or after enjoying a meal at Buffalo Wild Wings.
Can I visit a coffee shop near Buffalo Wild Wings in New Castle?
Yes, Scooter's Coffee, a coffee shop and restaurant, is nearby and is a good spot for a coffee break in conjunction with your visit to Buffalo Wild Wings.
Where can I find liquor stores close to Buffalo Wild Wings in New Castle?
Nearby liquor stores include Indiana Liquor Group, Hi-Way Liquor Store, and Noble Wine & Spirits, offering convenient options for beverages to complement your visit.
Are there any beauty or spa services near Buffalo Wild Wings in New Castle?
Yes, Beaute Spa, Crave Color Salon, and Vain Salon are nearby places where you can enjoy beauty and spa services before or after your meal.
What other dining options are available near Buffalo Wild Wings in New Castle?
Nearby dining options include Arby's and Subway, both offering fast food and sandwich options close to Buffalo Wild Wings.