Sandwich RestaurantFast Food RestaurantRestaurantTake Out RestaurantCaterer
Your local McCordsville Subway® Restaurant at 9661 Olio Road brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6" sandwiches, wraps, and salads, ordered quickly in the app or online, through convenient delivery, in-restaurant dining, or curbside pickup. We’re proud to offer a fresh alternative to typical fast food with fresh-cut veggies, tasty proteins, fresh-baked bread, and delicious cookies. We’re also here for your catering needs. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.
Overcharged for sandwiches. Online order - didn't order bbq sauce on sub, they accidenrly put bbq sauce on and instead of remaking, they tore the bbq bread out.
BS
Brittany Stumpf
Sep 21, 2025
1.0
No longer takes any coupons, no signs posted, very rude we could either leave or get them full price.
PB
Philip Bader
Oct 6, 2024
5.0
Update 02/07/2025: Wife coaxed me in. The place is renovated and clearly under new management. Dude loaded up my sandwich like the old days. Great experience. Will be back.
Previous Review:
I don't know if this place is under new ownership recently or what, but the level of stinginess with any of the sandwich fixins is absurd.
The woman making my sandwich must have been counting spinach leaves and grains of parmesan. It was like she felt she was shaking money onto the sandwich. Honestly she looked in pain, maybe they need a better line on Parmesan cheese pricing.
The veggies are all sliced so thin it reminds me of that scene from Fun and Fancy Free where Mickey Mouse is making paper thin slices of food to share with his friends. So everything is sliced thinner, cut into smaller pieces, and counted. The objective is not to make a good sandwich, it is to keep the margin as high as possible.
Another cool thing about this location is they have now obscured the part of the station where they put the meat and cheese on so you can't see how much of anything is going on the bread. I assume this is strategic.
I don't know if any of the above is unique to this location. In the past I had the owner snap at me for having the audacity to try and use a coupon from the national chain. "COUPON NO GOOD FOR OWNER", he yelled at me. Maybe it's the economy, maybe this location is just bad. I hope they put a Jersey Mike's in at 104th and forced to compete.
What are the operating hours of Subway at Geist Corner Shoppes?
Subway at Geist Corner Shoppes is open daily from 8:00 AM to 9:00 PM, with special holiday hours on November 26, 2025 (8:00 AM to 6:00 PM) and closed on November 27 and December 25, 2025.
Does this Subway location offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, this Subway offers in-store pickup, curbside pickup, and delivery services for your convenience.
Where is Subway located in McCordsville, IN?
Subway is located at 9661 Olio Road, Geist Corner Shoppes, Hancock, McCordsville, IN 46055, USA.
What kind of meals does Subway Geist Corner Shoppes serve?
They serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner, featuring fresh-baked bread, sandwiches, wraps, salads, and cookies.
Can I get catering services from this Subway restaurant?
Yes, catering services are available to help with your event or group orders.
Does this Subway location have dine-in options?
Yes, dine-in service is available at this Subway location.
How can I order from Subway Geist Corner Shoppes online?
You can order online or use the Subway app through their official menu link: https://subway.com/en-us/restaurant/42409-0/menu.
What notable nearby places are close to Subway at Geist Corner Shoppes?
Nearby places include Papa Johns Pizza, Anytime Fitness gym, and Good Fella's Italian restaurant, which you might explore before or after your visit to Subway.
Are there fitness centers near Subway Geist Corner Shoppes?
Yes, Anytime Fitness and Fishers Fit Body Boot Camp are nearby gyms that customers can visit.
What other dining options are available near Subway at Geist Corner Shoppes?
Nearby dining options include Good Fella's Italian and American cuisine, Happy Cuisine serving Chinese and sushi, and McDonald's for fast food.