Mr Gatti's Pizza

Reviews

• SD

  Steve Davis

  Apr 16, 2026
  5.0
  Can't say about the buffet, but did a carry out order it was spot on and some of the best pizza I've had in a while. moved back to Indiana from Florida glad it's in Martinsville.
• DE

  Doris Eldridge

  Mar 27, 2026
  5.0
  We drove 2 hours and were not disappointed! It brought back memories from our earlier years.
• DW

  Drew Willis

  Mar 15, 2026
  4.0
  We haven’t been here in a little while but typically when we do we Oder to-go, usually we get Strombolis with everything on them, which comes with chips and dill spears. Love them, can request sauce on the side which is always nice. Very much recommended.
• JB

  Jackie Bergeron

  Feb 28, 2026
  1.0
  After checking the website hours on 2/27 we made our way to Mr.Gatti's, we arrived about 8:10pm. We paid and the cashier never mentioned that the buffet closes at 8:30pm. At about 8:15ish the waitress puts her 2 plates of food down on a table near us I'm assuming she is going on break and looks at me with a dirty look and starts running her mouth about something clearly upset from her facial expression and when I go to say something she turns around walking towards the back still talking about something she is upset about, again I can't understand her, I honestly thought she was under the influence by the way she was acting. About 8:26pm the watress comes tapping on my husband's shoulder (not a gentle tap) made us think there was an emergency the way she was touching my husband and in a extremely angry tone says that we need to hurry up because they close in 4 mins , turns around and is still talking in a angry tone while walking away but we couldn't understand her she was so upset. The watress could of explained this a million different ways and she chose the rudest way. We left our full plates of food on the table went up to the register area and a female cashier approaches us and she is also very angry and points to a sign under their phone that doesn't even face the customers and says "OUR HOURS ARE POSTED" and she walks away. Absolutely mind blown how they handled this situation. They made a simple situation that could of been explained nicely a very awful experience because the way they chose to handle it. Food was good, the 3 bites we had, but never again will I spend my money at the Gattis in Martinsville.
• AG

  alisa goodman

  Feb 21, 2026
  3.0
  Haven't been to a Mr. Gattis for years. It was a little disappointing. The pizza on the buffet was dry and no freash on the bar when we first got there. They finally put 2 freash after we were there for awhile. The salad bar was decent. The ice cream machine is broken. It has a lot of potential but just didnt hit the mark.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mr Gatti's Pizza