Mr Gatti's Pizza

4.2
1247 reviews

About

Pizza RestaurantBuffet RestaurantArcadeVideo ArcadeFamily Style RestaurantChildren's Party ServiceEvent VenueChicken Wings RestaurantTake Out RestaurantRestaurant Delivery ServiceMr. Gatti's Pizza
Since 1969, we've been committed to creating unforgettable moments for all of our guests and having the best pizza in town!

Details

  • Dine-inAvailable
  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Requires reservationsNot available

Location

Mr Gatti's Pizza
620 State Road 39 Byp S, Martinsville, IN
46151, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.2
1,247 reviews
5 stars
700
4 stars
281
3 stars
131
2 stars
56
1 star
79

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Customers reported inconsistent food quality, with many mentioning cold or dried-out pizza and a lack of fresh options on the buffet.

Service

While some reviews praised the friendly staff, others highlighted poor service, particularly regarding buffet replenishment and customer interactions.

Cleanliness

Mixed feedback on cleanliness; some found the restaurant clean and well-maintained, while others reported unsanitary conditions.

Buffet Experience

The buffet was frequently criticized for being understocked and not meeting expectations, with some customers expressing disappointment in the variety and freshness of the food.
  • BW
    Brandee Wollam
    Dec 27, 2025
    1.0
    The food was cold and gross. Definitely not worth the money spent. And the food on the salad bar tasted like dish water ... if dish water had a taste.
  • BS
    Boom City Studio
    Dec 23, 2025
    5.0
    Love this place! Always super Delicious and Stellar Options!!
  • SA
    Samantha Acevedo
    Dec 13, 2025
    5.0
    Every time there is a snow storm we trek our way to Ghatti's and they never disappoint. Food was fresh and they asked if there were any pizzas we wanted them to make even though there weren't many people there.
  • HW
    Hannah Whaley
    Nov 4, 2025
    1.0
    Staff was friendly but overall the buffet was bare, there was only a few options and it was picked through. Also negative points for the ice cream machine being broken😔
  • TH
    The Traveling Hairs
    Oct 30, 2025
    2.0
    Tried Gatti’s buffet twice this week. Sunday night and Wednesday night. Both times the buffet was about half full and the pizza was dried out. Maybe you should put timers on them and throw them away after a certain amount of time. Quality is no where close to what it use to be.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mr Gatti's Pizza

What are the opening hours of Mr Gatti's Pizza in Martinsville?

Mr Gatti's Pizza in Martinsville is open daily from 10:30 AM to 10:00 PM.

Does Mr Gatti's Pizza offer delivery and pickup services?

Yes, Mr Gatti's Pizza offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.