At Papa Johns Pizza in Lafayette, IN, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Lafayette pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Lafayette or stop by 2404 Greenbush Road for carryout to order the best pizza in Lafayette, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Numerous customers reported poor service, including rude staff, long wait times, and unfulfilled orders.
Food Quality
Many reviews highlighted issues with food quality, such as cold pizzas, incorrect toppings, and overall dissatisfaction with the product.
Delivery Problems
Customers frequently experienced delays and issues with delivery, often resulting in cold food and missing items.
Mixed Experiences
While some customers praised the food and service, many others expressed frustration, indicating a lack of consistency in performance.
AA
Axel
5 days ago
1.0
Ordered a pickup from this place. Will admit I made a mistake in the ordering process which I didn't learn about until I came back home which is on me, but when I arrived (under the assumption my order was successful), I stood in there for over 15 minutes with absolutely ZERO acknowledgement from any staff. There was a lady in front who was there for at least half an hour and was still there after I left (parked in a no parking spot with the car still running AND a baby in it by the way, at night). I finally got fed up and left after I actively asked for help to figure out what I did wrong with the order and got ZERO response or acknowledgement that I had said anything. completely ignored. I need to make a habit of checking reviews before I go to places. do not go here.
CS
C Smith
Feb 10, 2026
1.0
Don’t waste your money! They use DoorDash to deliver and it arrives 30 mins after it leaves the store, cold. Take your money to dominos
SS
slo1418
Jan 25, 2026
1.0
DO NOT order dips with your delivery order. You will pay for them, but will never receive them! Then you’ll try and talk with the manager, and she does not care that you didn’t receive what you ordered. Just an fyi!
ED
eliseo duran
Dec 14, 2025
1.0
I see why ratings are so low. I had to wait because someone couldn't login??? Nobody really wanted to do anything about it. Don't come here I counted 5 people
23
2 3
Dec 10, 2025
1.0
My husband accidentally dropped and spilled his sodas and the just workers looked at him and laughed. 👎