At Papa Johns Pizza in Jeffersonville, IN, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Jeffersonville pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Jeffersonville or stop by 1616 East 10th Street for carryout to order the best pizza in Jeffersonville, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Numerous customers reported long wait times for orders, poor communication, and rude staff interactions.
Food Quality
Many reviews indicated inconsistent food quality, with complaints about undercooked or poorly made pizzas.
Positive Staff Interactions
Some customers praised friendly and helpful staff, particularly during in-store interactions.
Delivery Problems
Several reviews highlighted issues with delivery, including orders being late, incorrect, or mishandled.
Mixed Experiences
While some customers enjoyed their meals and service, many others expressed disappointment, indicating a lack of consistency.
JB
Jim OTIS Bergin
Jan 1, 2026
1.0
The worker was to busy on a personal phone call using vulgar language and didn't give me the right order
AR
Alicea Rudolph
Dec 17, 2025
5.0
Keshaonna check me out an she was amazing 🤝
LP
Les Pollitt
Dec 4, 2025
1.0
Ordered several pizzas in the afternoon for a 6 o’clock delivery. Didn’t arrive so called the store and was told they were running a bit behind but our order would be there shortly. Called again at 7 PM and was told pizzas were cooking and they would be there shortly. Called at 7:30 and was given another excuse. Cancelled the order at that point much to the dismay of the lady answering the phone who responded with, “it’s almost done. Are you sure?” Avoid this store! I understand it’s cheap pizza but that is meaningless if the pizza doesn’t actually get delivered. The store is poorly run and not honest with customers. Avoid avoid avoid.
BD
Benjamin Durcholz
Oct 25, 2025
2.0
Food is what you expect but oh my god they consistently take 50+ minutes to make a pizza even after the app says it is ready.
MW
Morgan Wilkens
Sep 12, 2025
1.0
Ordered delivery, they directed it to DoorDash, and it sat there for a minute I called the manager, answered the phone, trying to be funny sounding country. Then he proceeded to talk normal I asked if my pizza was gonna be delivered he said hold on I’ll check. Never came back to the phone, I called back and he never answered. This will be the last time I order from them