Sandwich RestaurantFast Food RestaurantRestaurantTake Out RestaurantCatererSubway
Your local Indianapolis Subway® Restaurant at 5535 N Keystone Ave brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6" sandwiches, wraps, and salads, ordered quickly in the app or online, through convenient delivery, in-restaurant dining, or curbside pickup. We’re proud to offer a fresh alternative to typical fast food with fresh-cut veggies, tasty proteins, fresh-baked bread, and delicious cookies. We’re also here for your catering needs. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.
Several customers reported issues with food quality, including food poisoning, spoiled ingredients, and incorrect orders.
Customer Service
Mixed reviews on customer service; some praised friendly staff while others reported rudeness and poor communication.
Cleanliness
Multiple reviews highlighted unsanitary conditions, including dirty facilities and concerns about food handling.
Order Accuracy
Numerous customers experienced problems with order accuracy, receiving incorrect items or missing components.
JJ
Joel
2 days ago
1.0
My Daughter got food poisoning from eating at this place yesterday, this place needs to be close down as soon as possible or I will sue this place and or take actions into my own hands, this happened 2/23/2026
AS
Alexia Shurill
Nov 21, 2025
1.0
Can’t follow simple instructions. I usually order in person but today I had to rush back to work .I am not sure why they will have people who do not even speak proper English answer the phone and tried to read off what’s supposed to be on my sandwich. Picked up my sandwich and everything was completely opposite then what was supposed to be on it ! She was not listening and was I believe Indian . Continued to talk over me on the phone and all . Not willing to correct my to go order.
AG
Anderson Grossman
Oct 11, 2025
1.0
Missed toppings and almost no meat
TR
Tyree Rayford
Sep 17, 2025
1.0
Cannot follow directions. Preemptively putting toppings on before customer can answer.