Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• CH

  Craig Hill

  Nov 10, 2025
  3.0
  Been ordering here for over a decade. You changed your tomatoe sauce to something that is acidic or base or something not so good. And dint appreciate it when the door dash guy leaves the pizza on the concrete cools porch without ringing the door bell or knocking on the door when the order says "Hand it to me".
• BK

  Brandon Kollar

  Nov 10, 2025
  5.0
  Great help, I called in for a lunch and learn order and they started it while I was on the phone.
• KC

  Katie Cipriani

  Oct 18, 2025
  5.0
  I ordered a pizza around 11:30 pm tonight. I got a notification that it would be delivered through DoorDash (which i have the WORST luck with). An hour goes by, no update on the order. I called the store and spoke to Chris, who was extremely kind. He said the order had been ready but they were just waiting on a dasher to pick it up. Honestly at that point, I figured I wasn’t going to get my order. 20 minutes later (12:50 am at this point) Chris calls me back to tell me he confirmed a driver was on the way. He apologized profusely and said he was going to remake the pizza so it was fresh. He went above and beyond, especially as they were 10 minutes from closing and the entire situation was out of his control. Thank you Chris!!!
• AC

  Andrew Calloway

  Aug 31, 2025
  2.0
  Went in to the store today, no menus anywhere displaying available food or prices. Stood there for about 30 seconds, no employees. Did this place close down and someone just forgot to lock up?
• JS

  Jessica Small

  Jul 28, 2025
  2.0
  Eh. The people are nice. The atmosphere is fine. But they constantly get the crust type wrong and don't ever actually give "extra sauce." They barely give regular sauce. It's cheese on bread with bubbled up dry spots. I only go to this location when it's the closest one. I'm usually closer to another location with HORRIBLE service and longer than acceptable service times, but the pizza is always correct. In my last order at this location, I ordered 2 New York style crust pizzas with extra sauce, clean cut (I have food allergies). What I got was 2 regular crust pizzas with too much sauce at the crust but dry throughout the main part of the pizza (like cheesy bread, not pizza). There were a couple of bites with very little sauce under the cheese, but most of it was literally just cheesy bread. It wasn't "little sauce" by my standards because I get extra sauce, it was really almost no sauce except for at the crust. I only get extra because we always have leftovers and reheating it makes it dry without extra sauce. And now I have to worry about whether or not they actually did a clean cut. This is my fourth time ordering from this location since Spring, and it has only gotten worse. This is not the first time they messed up the crust and not even the second time they barely gave any sauce throughout the pizza. I think I'll just start going down Meridian into Indianapolis for the next closest Papa John's when I'm on that side of town. Or order from a different pizza place entirely. If you report an incorrect order online, they'll never reach out to correct it. Save yourself some money if you plan on getting anything other than regular crust or if you actually want sauce on your pizza.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza