Grocery StoreDeliBakerySupermarketButcher ShopProduce MarketHealth Food StoreVitamin & Supplements Store
Fresh Thyme Market is a grocery store and natural food marketplace in Indianapolis, IN that provides healthy food and healthy values, with an atmosphere reminiscent of your local farmers market. We are committed to offering a variety of Clean Label products, free from artificial colors, flavors or preservatives, as well as many organic options. We carry many items catering to those following vegan, paleo, keto, vegetarian or wheat- and gluten-free diets, as well as anyone on a journey towards healthier, more delicious living.
Customers appreciate the fresh produce and specialty items, but there are concerns about spoiled products and quality control.
Customer Service
While many reviews highlight friendly and helpful staff, there are notable complaints about rude cashiers and poor service experiences.
Store Cleanliness
The store is generally reported as clean and well-organized, but there are serious complaints about the condition of the bathrooms and some food items.
Pricing
Prices are perceived as high, with some customers feeling overcharged, especially regarding promotions and sales.
Checkout Experience
The shift to self-checkout has received mixed reviews, with some customers frustrated by the lack of staffed lanes and issues with the self-checkout machines.
LK
Lehticia Kendall
Dec 19, 2025
5.0
Fresh Thyme has been a go to since it opened for quality produce and specialty food items I can’t find other places. They have a wide variety of gluten free foods and flours that have made my life easier over the years. Also love their selection of natural and organic body and face care!
VD
Valerie Devereux
Dec 12, 2025
5.0
I love this store. I found everything I needed right away. Sometimes just by accident.
LL
Logistican8000
Nov 22, 2025
1.0
Be prepared to spend a very large amount of time waiting at the deli counter. Something needs to change asap. And when I say "very" I mean enormous.
JK
Jess Kamm
Oct 30, 2025
5.0
Thanks for all your help & caring heart, Jen!
TH
Tim Hawkins
Oct 16, 2025
3.0
Selection of what little they carry is not great. High prices.