Einstein Bros. Bagels

3.8
295 reviews
Smoky brisket and melty cheddar breakfast sandwich layered with egg and chipotle cream on a toasted jalapeño-cheddar bagel—fresh, bold, and crave-worthy

About

Bagel ShopBakeryBreakfast RestaurantCoffee ShopCafeEinstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros.® Bagels is your neighborhood bagel shop. We're proud to provide our guests with freshly baked bagels, breakfast sandwiches, coffee and much more. Visit an Einstein Bros. location near you today!

Details

  • Dine-inAvailable
  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Credit cardAvailable

Location

Einstein Bros. Bagels
3450 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
46268, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.8
295 reviews
5 stars
136
4 stars
69
3 stars
34
2 stars
16
1 star
40

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Customer Service

Mixed reviews on customer service; some praised staff for being friendly and helpful, while others reported rudeness and unprofessional behavior.

Order Accuracy

Frequent issues with order accuracy, including missing items and incorrect orders, leading to customer frustration.

Wait Times

Long wait times reported consistently, with many customers expressing dissatisfaction over delays in receiving their orders.

Food Quality

Food quality is generally praised, particularly for bagels and breakfast sandwiches, but some customers noted inconsistencies and issues with freshness.

Cleanliness

Concerns raised about cleanliness, particularly in the dining area and bathrooms, impacting overall customer experience.
  • MN
    Michael Nicholson
    5 days ago
    5.0
    I had the best customer experience here. We ordered on the app, but it chose the wrong store as we were in Carmel. It placed the order to this store instead (our normal store). The management here made it right. They went above and beyond and made sure that I did not pay twice for a single order. Very rarely does a business work this closely with a single customer to make sure they are happy. They have earned my continued business. I hope others read this and can trust that on the rare occasion something goes wrong, this location will go the extra mile to satisfy the customer. 5 Stars! Love the food! Great as always.
  • JB
    John Bellinger
    Dec 1, 2025
    1.0
    The manager I’m assuming ? Not quite sure .. Whomever answered the phone this morning is entirely RUDE. I ordered from UBER EATS and it clearly asks you do you want your bagel TOASTED SLICED AND IT ASK WHAT TYPE OF BAGEL .. NOWHERE IN THE OPTIONS DOES IT ASK YOU ABOUT A SPREAD AND OR IS THEIR AN OPTION TO GET A SIDE OF ONE !!! I called to specify that and the lady whom answered the phone gave me a stern chuckle and proceeded to state they always give you a spread option. ! Like ma’am if they gave me the option I would’ve selected it and we wouldn’t be on the phone? Clearly she hasn’t been on the Uber Eats platform ever and or in some time or she would know. I know from working in the industries certain businesses allow/deny what can be placed on these 3rd party sites, so its possible this is one of those occasions and or strictly for bagels only are spreads not applicable I’m not sure all I know is the lady is rude and needs to be addressed via answering phones
  • RB
    Ronald Balcom
    Nov 29, 2025
    3.0
    Good food, terribly slow!
  • DO
    Dean Ohde
    Nov 1, 2025
    1.0
    Feel the need to say online ordering not working. Tried 3 times through the website. Going elsewhere
  • SG
    sai krishna Gutta
    Oct 26, 2025
    4.0
    New Update: went to store and showed them the receipt and pictures and they did offer free bagels to make it right which was outstanding in terms of service. Would definitely visit again. Did a take out order in which we had 3 jalapeño cheddar bagels with Jalapeño salsa. When we came home and opened the bagels, there was no jalapeño salsa on any of the bagels. Tried reaching out to the store for about 15mins but no one is picking the calls. Mistakes do happen but people not responding would be a deal breaker. Wouldn’t recommend going to this place.

Frequently Asked Questions About Einstein Bros. Bagels

What types of food and beverages does Einstein Bros. Bagels offer?

Einstein Bros. Bagels offers freshly baked bagels, cage-free egg sandwiches, breakfast sandwiches, deli lunch sandwiches, signature double-whipped cream cheese shmear, cold brew, hot coffee, pastries, and more.

Where is the Einstein Bros. Bagels location in Indianapolis?

The Einstein Bros. Bagels is located at 3450 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46268, United States.