At Papa Johns Pizza in Hartford City, IN, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Hartford City pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Hartford City or stop by 120 N. WALNUT STREET for carryout to order the best pizza in Hartford City, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Hi so I love eating here I’ve always had a great experience. To Noah Conners comment I was in there the day that you and your wife were there and you guys were never asked to leave on top of that if they can’t make the pizza and didn’t receive your order because they do not carry that pizza then what do you expect to happen lmao. I’ve tried to order the burger pizza before and had been told that they do not carry it at their location and I moved on with my life. Sometimes it’s better to listen rather than screaming and calling someone names over a pizza.
AA
Amber
Jul 7, 2025
5.0
Vincent c is the nicest and most helpful when it comes to ordering when they are busy he always has a good attitude and is very kind always offering more than be needs he is very professional and kind anytime we come in he offers to hold the door on the way out and makes sure we don’t need plates or anything like that he is just always so kind and polite and goes above and beyond to make sure we have everything we need 10/10 would recommend
SD
Sheila Davis
Nov 26, 2021
1.0
I set up my order for 5:30. I called to check on it because the order summary wasn't showing everything I ordered they said order would be ready at 5:30-5:40. Ok fine. I left my home at 5:10 and got a text message that my order was already ready. So it sits for 10 minutes while I get there. I'm really trying to be easier going about things these days because places are having trouble getting enough staff but that is no excuse for just not caring. The staff is nice enough when they are aware they have customers and aren't playing on their phones. So I get my order and when I get home, the order is wrong. Received the wrong crusts and my garlic knots are burned. Needless to say, Papa Johns will no longer get my business. Not that that really matters to them.