At Papa Johns Pizza in Greenfield, IN, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Greenfield pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Greenfield or stop by 1001 N STATE ST for carryout to order the best pizza in Greenfield, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Customers frequently reported long wait times, order mix-ups, and poor customer service experiences.
Food Quality
Many reviews mentioned inconsistent food quality, including burnt pizzas, missing toppings, and unsatisfactory preparation.
Cleanliness Concerns
Several customers expressed concerns about cleanliness and sanitary practices in the kitchen.
Parking Problems
Customers noted that the parking lot is small and often congested, making it difficult to access the store.
Mixed Experiences
While some customers had positive experiences with friendly staff and good food, many others reported significant issues, leading to a generally negative perception.
RS
Randall Schuyler
Jan 4, 2026
2.0
Pizza was hard ! Tasted like Pizza Hut cardboard pizza in the day. Crust was dry ! Pizza is shrinking at Papa John's ! We ordered a large pizza with 5 topping looked like a medium. So we ordered a medium pizza from Domino's. Pizza was the same size as the large we ordered at Papa John's ! We i called in to order, I couldn't hardly understand the person on the other end ! English please ! We ordered 8 chicken wings. Damn those wings were TINY ! Does Papa John's get their chicken wings from Ethiopia ? Wings were no bigger than my thumb aside from two of them, And they weren't much bigger either. Hadn't ordered from Papa John's in over two years cause we'd heard negatives about the food that is sold there now. From here on it's Domino's Or Little Cesear's. Not changing our mind !!
JL
Jacob Layne
Jan 2, 2026
5.0
The food is always good
BB
Beth B
Dec 11, 2025
3.0
Either it's not done enough or to done too much I didn't order green peppers., they still owe me two pizzas from the last time they messed up, when I called to order them they told me they don't take orders over the phone how am I supposed to get pizzas that they owe to me if I don't order them over the phone?
GS
Greg Surface
Dec 1, 2025
3.0
Need a bigger lot only 6 good spots to park
AB
amanda butler
Nov 15, 2025
1.0
Pizza was good, but we waited 35 minutes past time it was ready to be picked up. I feel like they should stop taking online orders if they are running that far behind.