While many customers praised the pizza and calzones, there were several complaints about inconsistent quality, including undercooked pizzas and incorrect orders.
Customer Service
Feedback on customer service was mixed; some praised the staff for being friendly and attentive, while others reported issues with order accuracy and slow service.
Pricing
Several customers felt the prices were high relative to the quality of food received, with some stating that they expected better for the cost.
Delivery Issues
Numerous reviews highlighted problems with delivery, including cold food, incorrect orders, and difficulty reaching the restaurant by phone.
VV
Valerie
Feb 18, 2026
5.0
We’ve never had a bad pizza from B Antonio’s! Definitely the best pizza around
RE
Rochelle Eicher
Feb 8, 2026
5.0
Although very busy, the gal at the register was very kind, sweet and helpful. She is a master at multi-tasking
AH
Andy&Jill Haxton
Jan 31, 2026
2.0
ordered online and was excited but our 3 pizzas all had 3 large charred air bubbles on them and outer edges were on the darker/charred side really taking away the flavor of the pizza. It was really busy for carryout (5-6 of us waiting and a few dine in families) so I get kitchen was rushed but quality was not what we had in the past (ESPECIALLY FOR THE PRICE). Chain pizza places just throw then out the door, quality is not as important as the quantity. Kinda the way I feel ours was tonight, I want the "OLD B Antonio's" that made their pizzas with love and passion, believe me, we can tell!
MS
Mark Stultz
Jan 29, 2026
3.0
In the past we considered the pizza expensive but worth it. This time, not as good but, likely good enough for us to consider continuing to order.
ER
Emma Richardson
Jan 27, 2026
4.0
*Edit*
They reached out and refunded, I hope to have a more positive experience next time we eat here
The Sausage roll gave my husband food poisoning. So far the pepperoni calzone for my kid was safe, and my sandwich. Just upsetting to try a new place and get sick from the food 😬