Business Details
About
Pizza Restaurant
At Papa Johns Pizza in Fishers, IN, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Fishers pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Fishers or stop by 10574 E 96TH ST for carryout to order the best pizza in Fishers, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
Location
Hours
Reviews
3.4
150 reviews
5 stars
69
4 stars
14
3 stars
10
2 stars
17
1 star
40
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Order Accuracy
Numerous customers reported issues with incorrect orders, including wrong sizes and missing items.
Customer Service
Feedback on customer service was mixed; while some praised friendly staff, others experienced rudeness and unhelpfulness.
Quality Consistency
The quality of the pizza has been inconsistent, with some customers noting improvements while others reported poor quality and overcooked pizzas.
Delivery Issues
Many customers expressed frustration with long delivery times and incorrect deliveries, leading to dissatisfaction.
Positive Changes
Some reviews highlighted significant improvements in food quality and service over time, indicating a turnaround for the business.
- APAshlynn PattersonOct 29, 20252.0literally just ordered a 6.99 pizza for my toddler and this is how it was delivered… yall are dead wrong
- CMChris MartinJul 31, 20251.0I ordered two large pizzas and received two medium pizzas. Please see the pictures for proof. I worked for Papa John's for five years, and I was made aware of certain management using medium dough when large dough was either out or under proofed. Spoke with manager and of course she denied it. This place is horrible with its current management.
- RWRyan WarrenJul 22, 20255.0This place has went from "Zero to Hero" I posted a 1-star review several years ago at this location. I had ordered several times, and was more disappointed each time until i finally made a review and swore this place off.... Fast forward to now, my wife insisted that this place has changed and i am missing out by not ordering from here ever again...... So, finally i ordered $100 worth of Pizza for my family, and i was blown away by how good it was. But, a broken clock is right twice a day and maybe it was a fluke. So, ive ordered consistently for several weeks and this place gets better each time I order. I have never seen a Restuarant go from so bad, to so good without going out of biz, and re-opening. This location has became amazing, and they make amazing pizza. It is the best pizza you can order south of Chicago. I cant say it enough how impressive and how high this location has stepped there game up. To find better pizza than this you would have to go to a Italian gourmet pizza place. Look at the dates on the negative reviews. They are all from years ago. This restuarant may have the same name, but they have completely turned it around. Bravo!
- WSWhitney SeeleyJul 18, 20255.0I placed a large order for pickup tomorrow. Autumn and Steve were amazing! Great customer service.
- AGAlex GountrasJun 13, 20252.0Front counter person was not helpful and borderline hostile. They did not want to help anyone and acted very annoyed when I said I was missing sauces. It did not seem like they knew what they were doing and couldn’t even grab the ready box without completely forgetting the name I said like 3 times (while being dismissive). No one looked friendly. I understand a rush and being super busy (I’ve been in that position). I also get having a bad day. Please work on friendliness or at least a positive attitude for customers and for the rest of your team. We all get it, and are willing to wait; just don’t act annoyed by all customers walking in. It may just be a lack of training.
Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza
What are the delivery hours for Papa Johns Pizza in Fishers, IN?
Papa Johns Pizza offers delivery daily from 10:00 AM to 12:00 AM, with extended hours until 1:00 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Can I order Papa Johns Pizza for takeout, and what are the takeout hours?
Yes, you can order takeout from Papa Johns Pizza. Takeout hours are 10:00 AM to 11:40 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and extended to 12:40 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Does Papa Johns Pizza in Fishers offer contactless delivery?
Yes, Papa Johns Pizza provides no-contact delivery services for your safety and convenience.
Where is Papa Johns Pizza located in Fishers, Indiana?
Papa Johns Pizza is located at 10574 E 96th St, Fishers, IN 46037, USA.
What types of products are available at Papa Johns Pizza?
Papa Johns Pizza offers pizza, wings, desserts, breadsticks, cheesesticks, and beverages.
How can I place an order for delivery or carryout from Papa Johns Pizza?
You can order online for delivery or carryout via the Papa Johns website or their app, using the provided links for convenient ordering.
Is Papa Johns Pizza in Fishers open on major holidays?
Papa Johns Pizza is generally open on holidays like December 24 and December 31 from 10:00 AM to midnight but is closed on December 25.
Can I find other dining options near Papa Johns Pizza in Fishers?
Yes, nearby dining options include Star Sushi, China Garden, CR Heroes Family Pub, Thai Villa Cuisine, Dairy Queen, and Tonys Cafe Family Restaurant, offering a variety of cuisines.
Are there any nearby places where I can handle errands before or after grabbing pizza at Papa Johns?
Nearby places include CVS Pharmacy for medical and shopping needs, UPS Access Point for shipping services, Bitcoin Depot ATM, and a PPG Paints Store for retail needs, making it convenient to run errands around your pizza visit.
What nearby establishments offer services related to health and beauty around Papa Johns Pizza?
You can visit Atlas Chiropractic, AlignLife Chiropractic & Natural Health Center, HV Nail Studio, Machos Barber Shop 2, Beautopia Spa Medica, or Dowden Family Dentistry near Papa Johns Pizza for health and beauty services.