Numerous customers reported slow service, incorrect orders, and lack of attention from staff, leading to frustration and disappointment.
Food Quality
Many reviews highlighted inconsistent food quality, with complaints about overcooked wings, small portions, and missing items from orders.
Positive Staff Experiences
Some customers praised specific staff members for their exceptional service, indicating that there are employees who provide a positive dining experience.
Inconsistent Experience
The overall experience varied significantly, with some customers enjoying their meals while others had negative encounters, suggesting a lack of consistency in service and food quality.
WL
Wade Lewis
1 day ago
1.0
Went there on a Saturday night with my family. Walked in and the place was dead. Took forever to get seated because there was no host scheduled which is mind blowing bc the servers doing host job making only $2.13 an hour is insane. We were there for probably a good 2 hours. Not one manager in sight helping the 3 servers on the floor which their service sucked. I mean of course it would if they don’t staff it correctly. Felt bad for them! Horrible management!!
EC
Evan Corcoran
2 days ago
2.0
They seem to not be able to keep enough staff to accommodate serving people. The place is very dirty and there isn’t anyone to clean or prepare sitting. Servers forget simple things like silverware and asking for things they make you feel like you’re inconviencing them.
HD
Helga Davila
2 days ago
1.0
My husband and I ordered wings today and did not request the sauces on the side. Unfortunately, the wings arrived without any sauce at all. We contacted the restaurant to address the issue, but the manager’s response was unprofessional. She stated that she personally added the sauces, implying that our concern was untrue, rather than acknowledging the possibility of a mistake. As a result, we were left with wings that had no flavor and received no apology or resolution. The lack of accountability and the rude customer service were disappointing and unacceptable.
MH
M. H.
Dec 28, 2025
2.0
Mis-charged for the Pick 6 and when it was "resolved" it wasn't the correct price either (it went down less than one dollar). Rather than argue, we paid and left. Check your receipts or you likely will be over charged.
JA
Jourdan Allbright
Dec 12, 2025
2.0
Did a pickup order tonight and I should have known that something would be missing and checked my order. Got a 20 piece wing and large fries along with a kids burger with fries…..no fries in the bag! Seems minor but never fails with this place. Disappointed but expected. The chain is not known for great service or getting things right. Wondering when corporate will step in to make this place worth while. We enjoy the food when it’s cooked correctly. Would love to be able to count on BW3, but is of course the same song I hear on repeat from those that have tried BW3s anywhere in the world….awful service and more miss than hit food with great potential. $55 and a 40 minute drive there and back will be spent on Wingstop going forward.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Fishers, IN specialize in?
Buffalo Wild Wings specializes in award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings available in your choice of 26 sauces and seasonings.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Fishers, Indiana?
It is located at 13868 East 116th Street, Fishers, IN 46037, USA.
What are the operating hours for Buffalo Wild Wings in Fishers?
The restaurant is open from 10:30 AM to 11:00 PM on Monday and Sunday; 10:30 AM to midnight from Tuesday through Thursday; and from 10:30 AM to 1:00 AM on Friday and Saturday.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings in Fishers have a website where I can find more information?
Yes, you can visit their website at https://www.buffalowildwings.com/locations/us/in/fishers/13868-east-116th-street/sports-bar-679/ for more details.
Can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Fishers by phone?
Yes, the main phone number is +1 317-913-2999.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in Fishers suitable for takeout orders?
Yes, it is listed as a takeout restaurant as well as a sports bar and chicken wings restaurant.
What nearby places can I visit after dining at Buffalo Wild Wings in Fishers?
After your meal, you might want to visit LibertyX Bitcoin ATM for financial services, Orange Leaf for some ice cream, or Tasteful Times liquor store nearby.
Are there fitness centers near Buffalo Wild Wings in Fishers?
Yes, nearby fitness options include StretchLab, Anytime Fitness, and Orangetheory Fitness Fishers-Geist, making it convenient to combine dining with a workout.
Where can I find other food options close to Buffalo Wild Wings Fishers?
Close by, you have Big Apple Bagels for coffee and bagels, Jet's Pizza and Marco's Pizza for more casual dining choices.
Are there any personal care or shopping stores near Buffalo Wild Wings in Fishers?
Yes, you can visit Davinci Nails for beauty services, State of Grace Boutique or Apricot Lane Boutique for women's clothing, and Resharp for kitchen supplies nearby.