Freshieez

Reviews

• JM

  Jennifer Murrell

  Nov 17, 2025
  5.0
  I've had a lot of pizza in my lifetime...but believe me when I tell you that Freshieez is some of the BEST pizza I've ever had! I kept it simple for my first order, picking up the Quad 4 Plastics Family Pack, which comes with a salad that was large enough to feed three of us with a full bowl. The Italian dressing was amazing! I'm wondering if it's house-made...? The meal also came with a large order of breadsticks and marinara sauce, which were super yummy! Now, let's talk about the 16" pizza...I ordered a thick crust sausage and pepperoni because I'm a simple person with simple tastes. Freshieez pizza dough is delicious and it was cooked perfectly! Not doughy around the thick edges at all, and not burned. When I say it was cooked perfectly, I'm not exaggerating! I believe the sausage is made in-house, and the pepperoni wasn't greasy at all! And I could tell the mozzarella cheese was fresh. The meal also came with a "dessert chip" (I chose cherry), which is like a thin-crust pizza loaded with cherry pie filling and a mildly "cinnamony" icing drizzled over the top for a perfect balance of tart and sweet. The food was undeniably uh-MAY-zing, but the customer service blew me away! When they found out I had never ordered from them before, they made me complimentary freshly-baked "bread chips;" just like the cherry dessert chip, this was also a thinnish-crust garlic bread-type appetizer with parmesan cheese sprinkled all over the top. They then proceeded to make fresh dip samples for me...the Freshieez spread, which is a cream cheese and seasonings blend, and another dip with the Freshieez spread base mixed with Alfredo sauce. Can't remember what they called it, but it was fantastic! And they also gave us fresh garlic butter and two cups of fresh pesto sauce for dipping, just for being first-time customers. "The girls" were working that day (a Sunday afternoon), and they are a bunch of sweet, hardworking young ladies, including the owners' youngest daughter, Melloni. I can't remember the gal's name that was serving us the freebies, but she was so friendly and conversational...chatting with these gals felt like catching up with old friends. And we were lucky enough to be treated to some stand-up comedy by their delivery driver while he waited for another order to be finished. I didn't catch his name either, but I think he said he was the grandpa of the gal that made us the bread chips. Regardless, he was super funny and was proud to show off the size of the box liner for their "TINY" 36" pizza...which looks like it wouldn't fit in the back of my car! If I ever decide to invite friends over for a pizza party, I know which pie I'm going for. If you're still reading this, do yourself a HUGE favor and check out Freshieez for the best pizza around! And next time, I'm planning on ordering an ice cream cone while I'm there. They serve Hershey's ice cream and had (I think) around 12 flavors. Thank you, Freshieez, for a great first experience! My whole family LOVED the pizza, and you've gained customers for life!
• EL

  Erin Leiter

  Nov 8, 2025
  5.0
  Pizza is delicious, and even the salad was very good, and lots of it! There was a little misunderstanding, which was completely my fault, but even so they gave me 25% off my order. The delivery man was super friendly. The donations they are taking toward the Adopt-A- Family program as well as their partnership with community organizing such as the Elkhart Public Library’s Summer Reading Program is what really puts them over the top, and I love being able to support a great local company that gives back to the community in so many ways !
• MW

  Mark Warlick

  Nov 8, 2025
  5.0
  Try the deep dish 🍕!!! Its huge and it ranks up there at the level of great Chicago style pizzas. Seriously. They take pride in how these deep dish taste and look. You may have to call it in.
• BL

  Bill Levenhagen

  Nov 7, 2025
  5.0
  Everyone is polite and welcoming… the pizza was amazing I will definitely be back time and time again …. Thank you for the amazing pizza!!!
• AF

  Ashley Foulkes

  Nov 2, 2025
  5.0
  Brooke and Steve and the crew are so kind and help the community out at any given chance, the Pizza is amazing but more so the family behind the dough!

Frequently Asked Questions About Freshieez