Numerous reviews highlighted slow service, with long wait times for food and inattentive staff.
Food Quality
Customers reported inconsistent food quality, with complaints about overcooked wings and cold meals.
Staff Attitude
Several reviews mentioned rude or unprofessional behavior from staff, impacting the overall dining experience.
Management Concerns
Feedback indicated a lack of effective management, particularly during busy times, leading to poor customer experiences.
Positive Experiences
Despite the negative feedback, some customers praised specific staff members and enjoyed the atmosphere and certain menu items.
RC
Rachelle Coder
2 days ago
1.0
This is the worst buffalo wild wings ever! I waiting over an hour past my pick up time for my take out order, when I received the order I was missing part of it ( always count your boxes here) after getting my whole order and taking it home, we actually could not eat it as it was so burnt and honestly looked as if they gave me the oldest boneless wings they had, fries were hard and cold, and the tenders dry and burnt. Worst experience ever I do not recommend this place to anyone!! The picture below is on the left buffalo on the right medium. The buffalo ones were so old they dont even look like buffalo anymore as it just soaked in the burnt chicken.
JM
Jodi Massenzio
4 days ago
2.0
We got take out, I was there 5 minutes before it was supposed to be ready. It wasn't ready until 10 minutes past the time and we were missing some of our order and the worst part was the food was cold.
NF
nate frye
Jan 2, 2026
5.0
Didn't go in-store.. but, I mistakenly missed what time it truly was. Did a doordash order and got my food. First off thanks doordash driver! Second, I know it was late (10:32pm) and you guys wanted to go home, but my food was still delicious.. not 10-10 but 7.5 and I don't blame you! It was my fault but still COMPLETELY content with my dinner. Thank you!
RB
Rene Berube
Dec 30, 2025
1.0
If you want super dry and overcooked wings its the place to go. Why have tender chicken when you can eat overdone fryer tasting treats
DW
Donovan Walker
Dec 17, 2025
2.0
My first visit. It was ok. Could be better. The food taste great. But when the redish haired girl came out with our chips and dip it seemed so excruciating to her. Looking around to see who's looking at her maybe? Rude at best. Maybe she was just having a bad day. But in case she thinks shes better in someway. Thats the vibe I got. Seems like a kitchen hand?
I expect that when I enter a place of business people smile. Even if you dont like them smile. If your having a bad day, b Im sorry!! Smile! Maybe you think someone's looking at you? Geg over it smile! Or lock yourself in a closet lol but smile!! Our actual waitress was actually kind and smiled lots
Dec 17 2025.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart serve?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart serves award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with a choice of 26 sauces and seasonings.
What are the opening hours of Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart is open daily from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Elkhart?
Buffalo Wild Wings is located at 522 Windsor Avenue East, Elkhart, IN 46514, USA.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart?
You can contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart by phone at +1 574-226-0311.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart have an online presence?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings has an official website and is also present on Facebook, Yelp, Bing, and Google with dedicated pages for the Elkhart location.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart currently open?
Yes, the Buffalo Wild Wings location in Elkhart is currently open.
What nearby restaurants can I visit near Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart?
Nearby restaurants include Olive Garden, Culver's, Red Lobster, Callahan's Restaurant, Texas Roadhouse, North Garden, and Perkins Family Restaurant.
Are there hotels close to Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart for visitors?
Yes, nearby hotels include Baymont Inn & Suites Elkhart, Baymont by Wyndham Elkhart, WoodSpring Suites Elkhart, and Red Roof Inn.
Can I find coffee shops near Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart?
Yes, Starbucks is a nearby coffee shop where you can enjoy coffee or smoothies before or after your visit to Buffalo Wild Wings.
What other entertainment or services are located near Buffalo Wild Wings in Elkhart?
Nearby you can find various services and entertainment options such as Sylvan Learning of Elkhart for education, RVBusiness media, Kneading Therapy By Design spa, and Elkhart Indian Motorcycle dealers.