Business Details
About
DeliCatererGrocery Store
Italian Deli, Catering and Grocery Store
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.8
311 reviews
5 stars
281
4 stars
17
3 stars
6
2 stars2
1 star
5
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers consistently praised the freshness and flavor of the sandwiches, particularly the Italian beef and meatball subs.
Service
The staff, including owner Tony, received high marks for being friendly, welcoming, and attentive to customer needs.
Cleanliness
Many reviews highlighted the deli's cleanliness and well-maintained atmosphere.
Variety
Customers appreciated the wide selection of Italian items, including sandwiches, pastas, and imported goods.
Pricing
While some found the prices a bit high, most felt the quality justified the cost.
- JMJohn MelendezDec 30, 20255.0Saw a post from the owner of Turano Bread about Tony’s Deli in Dyer and had to stop in. Great choice using Turano, but the sandwiches themselves were outstanding—fresh, flavorful, and made right. The service from the girls working the counter was just as impressive: friendly, fast, and welcoming. Truly a hidden gem in Dyer, Indiana. Highly recommend.
- VLVal3 LoveDec 15, 20255.0Just left ! Best service I’ve had in a long time everyone including the young ladies were very nice and the food was an amazing ! Can’t wait to go back for the famous meatball sub !
- ACAmelia Jane CastleDec 13, 20255.0Such fun to find childhood favorite holiday treats and more😘😘!
- JJJessicaNov 28, 20255.0Fresh to order homemade goodness
- KRKristopher RossieOct 20, 20255.0Tony's is amazing. Everything I've had is fantastic and look forward to trying more. The meatballs are a must have. The paninis are fantastic and the cold pasta salads. Tony runs a great business and we are lucky to have a shop like his in the community.
Frequently Asked Questions About Tony's Italian Deli
What type of business is Tony's Italian Deli?
Tony's Italian Deli is an Italian deli, catering service, and grocery store.
Where is Tony's Italian Deli located?
Tony's Italian Deli is located at 3360 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, IN 46311, USA.
What are the operating hours for Tony's Italian Deli?
Tony's Italian Deli is open Monday through Friday from 11:00 AM to 5:00 PM, Saturday from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM, and is closed on Sundays.
Which payment methods are accepted at Tony's Italian Deli?
Tony's Italian Deli accepts American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Diners Club, Discover, Mastercard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
How can I contact Tony's Italian Deli?
You can contact Tony's Italian Deli by phone at +1 219-515-2012 or via email at tonyitaliandeli@gmail.com.
Does Tony's Italian Deli offer catering services?
Yes, Tony's Italian Deli provides catering services along with deli and grocery store options.
What nearby dining options are available around Tony's Italian Deli?
Nearby dining options include Ruben's Mexican Grill, H&R Catering Inc., Beggars Pizza, Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt, The Scrambled Diner, and Dunkin'.
Are there any fitness centers near Tony's Italian Deli?
Yes, NFBD Group Fitness and Anytime Fitness gyms are located near Tony's Italian Deli for your fitness needs.
What other services can I find near Tony's Italian Deli?
Nearby services include Edward Jones for financial advising, Sunny's Cleaners for dry cleaning and alterations, and Tang's Nail & Spa for beauty treatments.
Which nearby places can I visit along with Tony's Italian Deli for a full day experience?
You can visit Longwood Golf Course for leisure, stop by The Coffee Shop at Faith Church for coffee, and explore local shops like The Bookstore at Faith Church.