Gelsosomo's Pizzeria

Reviews

• JB

  Jackie Barnes

  1 day ago
  1.0
  This was the first time I’ve tried this pizza 🍕 and it was dry, the cheese didn’t taste like real cheese, 🧀 the sauce was whey to sweet , the mushrooms 🍄‍🟫 tasted like they came out a jar “definitely not fresh” The crust looked old and had no taste. Also the pizza wasn’t completely round, it looked like the slices were put together from another pizza. 🍕 You couldn’t taste the sausage, because the sauce was too thick. Overall the pizza 🍕 was very disgusting 🤮 I will never from there again . I give this place two 👎🏽 👎🏽 down . 🤢
• AB

  Antuan Barnes

  1 day ago
  1.0
  literally the worst pizza ever. my neighboring gas station has better pizza. Also it looked like they reheated and married a bunch of older pizzas very stale No cheese pull the crust is like a hard dough that is difficult to bite through the only thing i could taste is a weird sweet tasting sauce definitely not worth anything close to the 50$ that was spent this pizza honestly probably ruined all pizza for me.
• CG

  Corey Gibson

  Mar 28, 2026
  1.0
  Disappointed in the staff targeting people with different political affiliations. Pizza is not about politics. Was going to order them tonight until we saw discriminatory pricing. There's really no mature place for this for food. I get the "joke" but it crosses a legal line and really has no place here. Hope management can remove this asap and get back to running a pizza joint. Have done large group orders for parties (with people all over the political spectrum) but will not be doing that anymore.
• AG

  Anastasia Gibson

  Mar 28, 2026
  1.0
  This place is fine, but a deeper look at the menu….. I don’t need my pizza with a side of politics. I’m sure it’s a “cute” “joke”, but discriminatory charging is actually illegal, and they put it in print. If I want to order a BBQ style burger, will the staff ask my political affiliation and charge me accordingly? There are so many competitor pizza places in this area, good Crown Point citizens don’t need to continue their business here. They lost our order tonight and every night from now on. Only wish we saw this sooner and gave them less business. We have had many LARGE gatherings with hundreds (with an S) dollar orders from here, but no more.
• AP

  Ashley Payne

  Mar 28, 2026
  5.0
  Wanted to update my initial review and say that the owner Peter reached out and was great about rectifying the situation. Was very impressed with him as an owner and how much he cared about what had happened and wanted to make it right. Warning! They will steal your money at this location! We just had a pizza delivered. When I called in to order the delivery and at the end, they asked cash or card. I told them I had cash and at no point did they tell me they don’t carry change. When the driver came and I handed him my $60 for my $44 order I asked for $6 back to give the driver a $10 tip, only to be told they do not carry any change and all money goes to their manager and that they couldn’t do anything to help me. So not only was I charged $4 for delivery fee I was also forced to hand over an extra $16 to them for the pizza. Which from what the driver said, he doesn’t even get to keep. Stealing peoples money isn’t cool. Pizza wasn’t even that good. Will never order from here again and you shouldn’t either.

Frequently Asked Questions About Gelsosomo's Pizzeria