Many customers reported slow service, long wait times for food, and inattentive staff.
Food Quality
The quality of food was inconsistent, with several reviews mentioning cold or overcooked items.
Positive Staff Interactions
Some customers praised specific staff members for their excellent service and friendliness.
Management Concerns
There were complaints about management being inattentive or ineffective in addressing service issues.
Ambiance and Cleanliness
Several reviews noted unpleasant odors and cleanliness issues in the restaurant.
MM
Mary
Nov 14, 2025
2.0
Service & food were both bad. Waited 15 minutes to be seated. Thought it was because it’s Friday night and they were busy but they were less than half full. We waited 10 minutes for a server and when she finally came she was not friendly. I can deal with that if you’re quick and efficient but she wasn’t those things either. Appetizer came and she never brought napkins or silverware, when I flagged her down she acted put out that I even asked and then was in no hurry to bring them. . None of the food was hot, just barely warm but she never came back to check. The small side of Mac & cheese was cold and inedible. We didn’t ask for any ranch but got multiple cups with everything instead of the sauce we actually ordered. Waited a full 15 minutes for carry out boxes. Dirty tables everywhere the whole time we were there. Another server dropped a cup of ranch on the floor in the middle of the restaurant and just left it there- all the staff looked at it and just walked around it. Would not recommend this location.
SO
Scott Ogden
Nov 3, 2025
1.0
Went here a 7 pm on a Saturday night. Our server was trying, but she had so many tables that the service ended up being awful. The food took 1.5 hours to arrive after ordering. To top it all off, my wife and I both ended up with intestinal issues. We did share and appetizer, but nothing else. Only discovered it was the wings, when I reheated and ate the left overs 2 days later and had the same symptoms.
DN
DarkLord by Night
Oct 8, 2025
5.0
Arrived for a quick bite for lunch before heading off to work myself, food was done quickly and hot, cooked too perfection!!
DG
Dianna G
Oct 5, 2025
3.0
Good food, great service... but the bar and restrooms smell like sewage.
KS
Katie Struben
Sep 21, 2025
2.0
We went today and when we arrived the host was super nice…then it went downhill. Our waitress brought us and our kids our drinks and no straws so when she brought our nachos, my husband asked for straws and she seemed annoyed. We placed our order and waited…waited…waited. She walked past our table several times, never checked on us, seen if anyone needed refills, nothing. When we finally got our food, everyone’s was cold and dry. She asked my husband if he wanted another beer and he asked for water and I asked for a refill on my drink. She asked nobody else if they needed a refill and snatched my empty glass off the table. I went to speak to her manager and apparently was not the only table having issues. The waitress then came over and got snippy with me asking what I told her manager and what he said. I told her that I told him our food was cold and dried out and he was going to discount it. We then ran into another of her tables in the parking lot and they had the same issue and said they will not be back.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What types of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Columbus, IN offer?
Buffalo Wild Wings offers award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with 26 different sauces and seasonings to choose from.
What are the opening hours of Buffalo Wild Wings at 2035 Jonathon Moore Pike?
The restaurant is open daily from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Columbus, Indiana?
It is located at 2035 Jonathon Moore Pike, Columbus, IN 47201.
Can I order takeout from Buffalo Wild Wings at this location?
Yes, the location is categorized as a takeout restaurant along with a sports bar and chicken wings restaurant.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Columbus, IN?
You can reach them by phone at +1 812-375-1770.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings have an online presence where I can find more information?
Yes, you can visit their official page at https://www.buffalowildwings.com/locations/us/in/columbus/2035-jonathon-moore-pike/sports-bar-508/ for details.
Are there other food options near Buffalo Wild Wings on Jonathon Moore Pike?
Yes, nearby options include Jimmy John's sandwich shop, Ruyi Asian Restaurant, McAlister's Deli, Wendy's, Panda Express, and McDonald's, providing a variety of cuisines from sandwiches to Asian and fast food.
What nearby services can visitors to Buffalo Wild Wings access for their personal care needs?
Close by are several hair and beauty services including BoRics Hair Care, Supercuts, Sport Clips Haircuts, and Gossip Nails for haircuts, styling, and nail care.
For visitors needing telecommunications or mobile phone services near Buffalo Wild Wings, where can they go?
Nearby retailers include Verizon and TCC, Verizon Authorized Retailer, offering mobile phone products and services.
Are there convenient amenities close to Buffalo Wild Wings for travelers or customers?
Yes, there are lodging options like Super 8 by Wyndham Columbus and Super 8 Columbus Indiana nearby, as well as financial services such as Centra Credit Union and Western Union.