Overall, customers praised the food quality, with many highlighting specific dishes like pizza, mac n cheese, and steak as exceptional.
Service Consistency
While many reviews commended the attentive and friendly service, there were notable instances of poor service and mix-ups with orders.
Pricing Concerns
Several customers expressed that the prices were high relative to the portion sizes and quality, leading to mixed feelings about value.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere received mixed feedback, with some enjoying the friendly vibe while others found it noisy or outdated.
Takeout Experience
Takeout orders had mixed reviews, with some customers experiencing missing items or issues with food quality.
ND
Natalie DeWitt
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
Trevor maybe my favorite Armstrong!
KW
Kelly Workman
Nov 7, 2025
5.0
Carry out meal. Great food! Glad you have added sweet potato fries to your menu!
JH
Joe Heins
Oct 25, 2025
3.0
The online ordering told us to arrive at 5:58p. When we arrived, nobody was in the waiting area and the bartender was not aware of our order. We waited 20 more minutes. the meatball roll was incredibly soggy. They had made the meatball sandwich but not the chicken. The meatball sandwich sat for 20 minutes before it was given to us and the side order of broccoli was cold.
DB
Dr. David A Baillie
Oct 20, 2025
5.0
In town to work for a couple days and went here on someone's recommendation. Did not disappoint. Service, Kara, was excellent. Nice atmosphere. Big servings for the world's current price structure. Salad was excellent. Pizza was good, flavor reminiscent of Pizza Oven of Canton Ohio. Only negative is they used chopped pepperoni instead of slices but flavor was good. Would go back any time.
AH
Amber Highfill
Oct 18, 2025
5.0
The food was a 10/10. Best Mac n cheese by far. Burger was top notch, their new special (the weekend special with steak) was amazing. Their house made chips were perfection. Even their appetizer bread that gets served while dining in was perfection. My kids loved the spaghetti and the pizza. Will definitely be back. Also, the server, Trevor, was the best server we’ve had in awhile!
Frequently Asked Questions About The Italian Grille
What are the regular operating hours of The Italian Grille?
The Italian Grille is open Tuesday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, Friday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Saturday from 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM. It is closed on Mondays.
Does The Italian Grille offer delivery services?
Yes, The Italian Grille offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Can I order takeout from The Italian Grille?
Yes, takeout is available during the same hours as the restaurant's regular hours, closed only on Mondays.
Where is The Italian Grille located?
The Italian Grille is located at 227 S Duesenberg Dr, Auburn, IN 46706, United States.
How can I view the menu of The Italian Grille online?
You can view the menu online at https://theitaliangrille.com/menu.
Is there a phone number to contact The Italian Grille?
Yes, you can reach The Italian Grille by phone at +1 260-925-9400.
What type of cuisine does The Italian Grille serve?
The Italian Grille specializes in Italian cuisine, including pizza, pasta, sandwiches, chicken wings, salads, and vegetarian options.
Are there any pizza restaurants near The Italian Grille?
Yes, Marco's Pizza is a nearby pizza and Italian restaurant you may want to check out.
What other food options are available near The Italian Grille?
Subway, a sandwich and fast-food restaurant, is nearby and could be a convenient alternative.
Are there any healthcare facilities near The Italian Grille?
Yes, there are several including Beltone Hearing Care Center, Auburn Pediatric Dentistry, and Parkview Physicians Group - Cardiology, which might be useful if you have appointments nearby before or after visiting the restaurant.