Pie Five Pizza

4.3
194 reviews

About

Restaurant
Pie Five Pizza! Craft pizza, so fresh, so fast!

Location

Pie Five Pizza
537 Oakbrook Center, Oak Brook, IL
60523, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.3
194 reviews
5 stars
136
4 stars
20
3 stars
10
2 stars
7
1 star
21

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Mixed reviews on pizza quality; some praised freshness and taste, while others reported issues with spoiled ingredients and poor preparation.

Customer Service

Customer service experiences varied widely; some praised friendly staff, while others reported rude behavior and lack of concern for complaints.

Cleanliness

Multiple reviews highlighted cleanliness issues, including unsanitary conditions and poor food handling practices.

Value for Money

Customers appreciated the affordability of the menu, but some felt overcharged for certain items.
  • VG
    Vikas Goyal
    1 day ago
    5.0
    Best vegetable pizza we ever had.
  • JT
    Jodie Teibel
    Jan 2, 2026
    2.0
    Came here tonight and the two kids behind the counter were rude as heck! We were literally bothering them to approach the counter and place an order.
  • MW
    Mariah Whittington
    Dec 27, 2025
    2.0
    They served me a margarita pizza with no basil. No attempt was made to fix it. Just a “sorry”
  • JN
    jack nowakowski
    Dec 12, 2025
    5.0
    Stopped here for a quick bite while doing some holiday shopping and was pleasantly surprised how good the pizza was!
  • MO
    Michelle Oglesby
    Oct 25, 2025
    1.0
    ⭐️ 1-Star Review: “Absolutely Disgusting Experience — Never Again!” I went to Pie Five Pizza in the Oakbrook Illinois Center, and let me just say — it was one of the most disgusting food experiences I’ve ever had. I ordered a pizza made with Alfredo sauce as the base, added my usual toppings, and chose a thin stuffed crust. Everything looked fine until I took my first bite. Immediately, I was hit with a sour, spoiled, almost putrid taste that made me instantly gag. I honestly had to fight not to throw up right there. I tried to figure out what it was, tasting the toppings one by one, but the moment I hit that Alfredo sauce again — that same revolting, rotten taste came flooding back. It was unmistakable. The sauce was bad. I took the pizza right back up to the counter and explained the situation. Instead of any concern or apology, I was basically told the only thing they could do was “make another pizza.” No one clearly said that the replacement would be charged again — which, honestly, was ridiculous given that the first one tasted spoiled. To make matters worse, the manager looked visibly annoyed and acted as if I was inconveniencing him by bringing back a pizza that could have made someone sick. His attitude was cold, dismissive, and downright rude. While standing there, I couldn’t help but notice that their cold toppings were uncovered and sitting out — obviously room temperature. At that point, it was crystal clear: this place does not take food safety or customer service seriously. Moral of the story? If you enjoy the thought of a sour stomach or an early grave, then sure — eat here. Otherwise, save yourself the nightmare and stay far, far away from this location.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pie Five Pizza

What type of food does Pie Five Pizza serve?

Pie Five Pizza serves craft pizzas that are fresh and made quickly.

Where is Pie Five Pizza located?

It is located at 537 Oakbrook Center, Oak Brook, IL 60523, United States.