Business Details
About
Restaurant
The Cellar Restaurant
Located downtown in the historic city of Geneseo, The Cellar Restaurant, is
alive with history. You will find us nestled in the lower level of a 130-year-old building known as the Geneseo House. We feature house-cut steaks, ribs, chops, and seafood; or maybe, you would prefer to try the House Specialty of Charcoal Broiled BBQ Shrimp. Our glassed-in kitchen allows you to view your food being prepared and, since we have staff with up to 43-years experience, you will find that they will welcome and
serve you as if you were old friends. For over 53 years The Cellar has been known for "Food Worth Traveling For".
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.7
648 reviews
5 stars
519
4 stars
82
3 stars
20
2 stars
10
1 star
17
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Service Quality
Many customers praised the attentive and friendly service, although some reported instances of rudeness and inattentiveness.
Food Quality
The food received high marks for taste and preparation, particularly the steaks, but there were complaints about inconsistency and some dishes being overpriced.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere was generally described as charming and nostalgic, though some reviews mentioned issues with seating arrangements and decor.
Value for Money
While many felt the prices were fair for the quality of food, others expressed disappointment over perceived value, especially when dishes did not meet expectations.
Consistency
The restaurant has a long-standing reputation for quality, with many customers noting that it has maintained its standards over the years, though some recent visits have raised concerns.
- WKWanda KAug 19, 20235.0We love having the round table so we can talk to each other!
- LMLinda & Mike MinnaertMay 21, 20232.0We have always loved the Cellar. Went there recently for anniversary and had an unbelievable BAD meal! Not one of us but both of us. Mushy catfish, tough shrimp with a bit of a different sauce and the rice was “glumpy” not fluffy. For the price we paid we were so disappointed. The service was excellent as always! We will be going somewhere else for our celebrations from now on. The 2 stars are for the service.
- RORodger Van OpdorpMay 10, 20195.0Always great food and service
Frequently Asked Questions About Cellar The
Where is The Cellar Restaurant located?
The Cellar Restaurant is located at 137 S State, Geneseo, IL 61254, in the lower level of the historic 130-year-old Geneseo House building.
What type of food does The Cellar Restaurant specialize in?
The Cellar specializes in house-cut steaks, ribs, chops, seafood, and their house specialty, Charcoal Broiled BBQ Shrimp.
What are the operating hours of The Cellar Restaurant?
The Cellar is open Wednesday through Sunday from 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM and closed on Monday and Tuesday.
How can I contact The Cellar Restaurant for reservations?
You can contact The Cellar Restaurant by phone at +1 309-944-2177 or email them at thecellar1960@gmail.com.
Can I watch my food being prepared at The Cellar Restaurant?
Yes, The Cellar features a glassed-in kitchen where you can view your food being prepared by their experienced staff.
What is the history behind The Cellar Restaurant's location?
The Cellar is located in the historic Geneseo House, a building that is over 130 years old, adding a rich historical atmosphere to your dining experience.
Are there any bookstores near The Cellar Restaurant where I can browse before dining?
Yes, Anthology for Books, a bookstore, is nearby, making it convenient to browse books before or after your meal at The Cellar.
What thrift and antique shops are close to The Cellar Restaurant?
Nearby you can visit Wildflower Vintage and Thrift and Mistygirlwiththejob, an antique store, perfect for vintage shopping before or after dining.
Is there a place nearby where I can get a massage or wellness treatment after dining at The Cellar?
Yes, Muscles In Motion Wellness Center and Dawn's Serene Escape are nearby wellness centers offering massage therapy and holistic treatments.
Are there any legal or financial services near The Cellar Restaurant?
Nearby you will find Paula Simosky-Simosky Tax & Accounting and Stone & Palmgren legal services for any financial or legal needs.