Einstein Bros.® Bagels is your neighborhood bagel shop. We're proud to provide our guests with freshly baked bagels, breakfast sandwiches, coffee and much more. Visit an Einstein Bros. location near you today!
Numerous reviews highlighted consistently rude and dismissive staff, creating a negative atmosphere for customers.
Food Quality
While many customers enjoyed the bagels and sandwiches, there were complaints about food being cold, burnt, or of poor quality.
Hygiene Standards
Several reviews pointed out unsanitary conditions, including dirty tables and questionable hygiene practices among staff.
Order Accuracy
Multiple customers reported issues with incorrect orders and long wait times, indicating a lack of organization and attention to detail.
Atmosphere
The decor and overall ambiance were described as dated and uninviting, contributing to a less enjoyable dining experience.
CC
Callum
3 days ago
5.0
Whoever took me on the register today is a pro, courteous, knows the menu, and can pivot between positions on a DIME. Whatever yall are getting paid is not enough for the energy and service you’re bringing. Be blessed and bountiful
KF
Kate F
Nov 14, 2025
5.0
Really nice lady this afternoon
RM
Ram M
Sep 23, 2025
1.0
Extremely disappointing experience. The staff were rude and dismissive, creating a terrible atmosphere from the moment I walked in. On top of that, the hygiene standards were questionable at best, which made me feel uncomfortable and unwelcome. Definitely not a place I would recommend and there are far better options that value.
RR
Reto
Sep 19, 2025
4.0
For lunch I got myself a Santa Fee bagel, for my wife a avocado/egg/tomato bagel. Th ride home was about 15" and there were still crunchy at arrival. The staff was helpfull, I switched the bagel type (and back) and the confusion was corrected in no time and they were helpful. The atmosphere is a bit dated, wish they refreshed the decor a bit.
JM
Joshua Martell
Sep 8, 2025
5.0
Ordered breakfast for a group through the catering menu online. Process was smooth, everything was ready and correct when scheduled. Would consider them again for future group orders.
Frequently Asked Questions About Einstein Bros. Bagels
What are the main products offered by Einstein Bros. Bagels in Evanston?
Einstein Bros. Bagels offers freshly baked bagels, cage-free egg sandwiches, deli lunch sandwiches, cold brew, coffee, pastries, and catering options including Baker’s Dozen bagel boxes.
What are the operating hours for Einstein Bros. Bagels at 1745 Sherman Ave?
Einstein Bros. Bagels is open daily from 6:00 AM to 2:00 PM, with special holiday hours on Christmas Eve (7:00 AM to 1:00 PM) and closed on Christmas Day.
Does Einstein Bros. Bagels offer online ordering or a mobile app?
Yes, customers can order online at their Evanston location website, and mobile apps are available on Apple App Store and Google Play named EinsteinBrosBagels for convenient ordering and gift cards.
Are there any special payment options accepted at Einstein Bros. Bagels?
Yes, the store accepts American Express, Apple Pay, Android Pay, Cash, Contactless Payment, Discover, MasterCard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
Does Einstein Bros. Bagels provide catering and pickup services?
Einstein Bros. Bagels offers catering services, in-store pickup, carry out, and WiFi for customers.
Are there any nearby coffee shops or cafes close to Einstein Bros. Bagels in Evanston?
Yes, nearby coffee options include Camille’s Sidewalk Cafe and Starbucks, both great spots to visit before or after enjoying bagels at Einstein Bros.
Which nearby fast food or casual dining restaurants are close to Einstein Bros. Bagels?
Nearby fast food and casual dining options include Taco Bell, Blaze Pizza, Jimmy John’s, and Koco Table Evanston, ideal for varied meal preferences around the area.
What other amenities or services can I find near Einstein Bros. Bagels on Sherman Ave?
Near Einstein Bros. Bagels you can find Floyd’s 99 Barbershop for grooming, US Cellular for mobile phones, and Oldberg Park for outdoor activities, making it convenient for errands or leisure.
Is Einstein Bros. Bagels open during holidays such as Christmas?
Einstein Bros. Bagels is closed on Christmas Day for multiple years but may have reduced hours on Christmas Eve, typically from 7:00 AM to 1:00 PM.
How can I stay connected or follow Einstein Bros. Bagels online?
You can follow Einstein Bros. Bagels on Instagram (@einsteinbros), Twitter (@EinsteinBros), Facebook (EBBShermanandClarkSEC), and watch their videos on their YouTube channel.