Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• MA

  Michelle Abegu

  Feb 14, 2026
  1.0
  I found three separate hairs (black, blonde, and black/white) in my pizza. This is a serious hygiene issue and very disappointing. Call the place and did absolutely nothing to help.
• BC

  Bill Challenger

  Feb 8, 2026
  1.0
  Wild that this place even has 3 stars. Ordered 2 and a half hours in advance to make sure my order would be ready on-time. Called when I was leaving 30 minutes before arriving to make sure they had the order and to make sure it would be ready on time. When I show up, they hadn’t even started making it. Have to wait 20 minutes in-store and get back to my Super Bowl Party 20 minutes late. Hard to imagine how you can run a location so poorly.
• AB

  Anthony Bertini

  Feb 5, 2026
  4.0
  Ordered 3 pizzas all came as order, hot and fresh. 👍
• JF

  Jason Franco

  Feb 4, 2026
  5.0
  Best pizza spot to go ever in elgin always come here every week they never disappoint staff is so friendly and helpful :) great jobs guys
• JJ

  Jan

  Jan 19, 2026
  1.0
  I live in a senior citizens community and last night we were watching the playoff games with the Bears and order the pizza through the Larkin Avenue Papa John's. Our pizza was supposed to have been delivered by 7:23 at 8:00 we were calling to find out where the pizza was and they told me that they didn't even have an order for us. Then we called doordash because we were having them deliver it and she said well I'm here waiting for the order. We called back to Papa John's and said that our delivery person was sitting there waiting and he said oh well she's just now picking up your order this was at 8:25 that is 1 hour past the time that our pizza was supposed to be delivered. Then they come with a pizza we ordered two large pizzas cheese and sausage what we got were two small pizzas half sausage and half just cheese I called the place back and told them that we were not going to pay for this and that they better give us a refund on our bill. The piece didn't even taste good it tasted like old stale crust hardly no sauce on it it was horrible would I recommend Papa John's to anybody not in my lifetime and my lifetime has been pretty long and I don't plan on going away yet but I will not refer Papa John's to anybody.!!!!!!