Prince Street Pizza

Reviews

• MQ

  Mabruk Quabili

  1 day ago
  3.0
  It was okay, sauce was too sweet, pizza was too hot, and all the toppings slid off the slice. Much better choices in Chicago. Staff was friendly. For NYC slices, Scar's and L'industrie are in different tiers of goodness than Prince Street Pizza.
• HK

  harmit kaur

  1 day ago
  2.0
  Got a couple slices for takeout. It seemed liked they were a day old or sitting under the lamp for hours. Super dry and hard to eat. Not worth $8 per slice price
• MA

  Michael A

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Pizza is fantastic. Dough and ingredients are top quality. The Green Machine is my favorite. Pesto, whipped ricotta, mushrooms etc, the flavors go together so well. If you like sweeter sauce the Sunset Square is excellent but heavy. I prefer the thin slices. Cons- the location stinks. Last time I went they were cleaning up graffiti off one of their walls inside. Who sprays graffiti indoors?? And you might have to avoid junkies on the curb. It’s also very small inside and gets cramped when a few people are in there. Sometimes feels stuffy or dumpy just because it’s so small even though it’s not that old. Open one in Lincoln Park or Lakeview instead and make it a little bigger!
• KG

  Khali Garland

  4 days ago
  5.0
  I've been living in Chicago my entire life, and this place is my absolute favorite to get Detroit style pizza and to just grab a slice in general whenever I'm around. The flavors are insanely creative and keep you coming for more with their unique and delicious taste. Not only is the pizza phenomenal, but the staff is also super cool. They are incredibly patient, persistent, and hospitable. Being in one of the busiest neighborhoods in the city, especially for night life on the weekend, they deal with some of the craziest customers, who are sometimes inebriated, and still show an amazing commitment to service. I wanna give a shoutout to some of the guys that I've become familiar with just from being a regular: Marty, Huey, Ray, Shawn, and Mike. It's way more but unfortunately I don't remember everyone's name. But everyone there is amazing, and moves super quick and efficient to satisfy their customers.
• NA

  Natasha Al-Rafie

  Apr 3, 2026
  3.0
  Got delivery from here on a Thursday night. I ordered the 18” pepperoni pizza with a side of “not ranch” and marinara. The pizza was pretty dry, not full of flavor and the crust was also very dry and burnt but not in the delicious crispy way, it was not a caramelized way. It was also seemingly trying to be a New York style but again missed the mark. I wouldn’t come back but the food was fine.

Frequently Asked Questions About Prince Street Pizza