Magnolia Bakery - Chicago

Reviews

• RG

  Ruchika Gupta

  Apr 6, 2026
  4.0
  Loved magnolia in NY so was excited to hear about this location in Chicago. Banana Pudding (4/5): Tasty but a lot more cakey and not enough cream compared to the one in NY. Pumpkin Spice (3.5/5): Good flavor but not as tasty as the original.
• VV

  Vanessa

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  Edward helped me and was very helpful when I had questions. I did not feel rushed, he was patient and nice. I got the banana pudding of course, cup cakes for my son and tried the carrot pudding. All of the stuff I got was great. (Forgot the fudge brownie) Thanks Edward!
• JN

  Johnny novo

  Apr 5, 2026
  1.0
  They laugh to your face, yet they talk behind your back—I saw it with my own eyes. They are not good people; they may be kind to some, but they certainly are not to others. And yet, I found a hair in the cake.
• LA

  Lyn A.

  Mar 27, 2026
  4.0
  It was good to see there is a Magnolia Bakery in Chicago. Oh my eyes widened and my feet immediately and directionally transported me across the street. Knowing Magnolia Bakery always tames my “adult sweet tooth” it was my moment to have desert ahead of dinnertime. Like a kid, I salivate over their classic banana pudding, red velvet “anything” and a Mocha to go. Today was a delish day!
• PH

  Patti Hanc

  Mar 23, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered on the Grubhub platform. They won’t let you leave reviews. Which is unfair to people making a decision. They currently have 4.9 rating. I placed my order yesterday. Not only are the portion sizes a joke, $4 for a tiny cookie, a “large” banana pudding is the smallest container. The prices just don’t match the portion. Cupcakes were super dry. Honestly, I would’ve ordered Sweet Mandy B’s instead but it wasn’t an option. The location in New York was amazing. This location in Chicago is a joke.

Frequently Asked Questions About Magnolia Bakery - Chicago