Customers frequently praised the pizza for its delicious flavors, crispy crust, and variety of options, particularly the 'Naughty Pie' and 'Fancy Prince'.
Service Experience
Many reviews highlighted the friendly and accommodating staff, with specific mentions of excellent customer service from employees like Spencer.
Inconsistency Issues
Some customers reported inconsistencies in pizza quality, with experiences of cold or burnt slices, particularly during busy times.
Atmosphere and Space
The restaurant is noted for its small size and crowded conditions, which can make dining in less comfortable, but it is still seen as a great grab-and-go option.
Value for Money
While many found the pizza to be reasonably priced for its quality, some felt it was expensive for the portion sizes or had mixed feelings about the value compared to other local options.
AM
Annie McIntyre
1 day ago
5.0
Could not have imagined a better pizza in my wildest dreams! The staff was super friendly and helpful. It’s gets busy on the weekends so plan accordingly! We traveled an hour + just to try the sicilian slice and wowww really did not disappoint. We’ll definitely be back, sooner than we’d care to admit I think! Keep up the great work 🤤
MN
Michi Naps
6 days ago
5.0
Delicious Pizza! I have the hot honey slice and omg 😭 def worth! My bf did have the meat lovers and said it was a bit dry. The bread was pretty thick and not enough sauce.
JJ
Joey
Nov 14, 2025
4.0
Square pizza was awesome. NY style isnt worth it. Too small of a location making it uncomfortable to order and wait for it.
CP
Chirag Patel
Nov 3, 2025
5.0
Fantastic choice of pies (pizzas). I highly recommend “The Naughty Pie”. A must-go-to when visiting the USA.
GS
Gerard O' Shea
Nov 2, 2025
5.0
Great spot, quality pizza, I'm only sorry I didn't have more time to try the different kinds of pizza on offer
Frequently Asked Questions About Prince Street Pizza
Does Prince Street Pizza accept reservations?
No, Prince Street Pizza does not accept reservations.
What are the opening hours of Prince Street Pizza?
Prince Street Pizza is open Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and on Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 3:00 AM.
Does Prince Street Pizza offer delivery or pickup services?
Yes, Prince Street Pizza offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
On which day does Prince Street Pizza offer takeout pies and Uber Eats delivery only?
On Tuesdays, Prince Street Pizza offers takeout pies and Uber Eats delivery exclusively.
What payment methods are accepted at Prince Street Pizza?
Prince Street Pizza accepts American Express, Apple Pay, cash, MasterCard, and Visa.
Is there seating available at Prince Street Pizza?
No, Prince Street Pizza does not have seating available.
Is parking available near Prince Street Pizza?
There is paid street parking and paid parking garages near Prince Street Pizza, but no free parking lots or street parking are available.
Where is Prince Street Pizza located?
Prince Street Pizza is located at 939 West Randolph Street, Suite 1W, Chicago, IL 60607, USA.
What nearby restaurants can I visit before or after dining at Prince Street Pizza?
Nearby restaurants include Dirty Root (American cuisine), Taco Bell Cantina (Mexican fast food), Marrakesh (Moroccan cuisine), Umami Burger (American burgers), La Mediterranee (Middle Eastern and French food), Porkchop (Barbecue), and Nonna's Pizza & Sandwiches.
Are there any nearby locations for grooming or beauty services near Prince Street Pizza?
Yes, nearby places for grooming and beauty services include Time Hair Gallery, J. Avienda Salon, Prohibition Barber Co, and Floyd's 99 Barbershop.
What entertainment venues are close to Prince Street Pizza that I can visit?
Nearby entertainment venues include Wiggle Room Chicago (concert venue and theatre), Everleigh Social Club (dance club and concert venue), and Fred Astaire Dance Studio (dance school).