Customers generally praised the pizza for its flavor and quality, with many calling it some of the best they've had in Chicago.
Service
The staff received consistent positive feedback for being friendly and attentive, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
Delivery Issues
Some customers experienced problems with delivery orders, including missing items and food quality concerns, particularly with garlic knots.
Pricing
Several reviews noted that the prices were on the higher side, but many felt the quality justified the cost.
Oiliness
A recurring complaint was the excessive oiliness of the pizza, which affected the overall enjoyment for some customers.
MM
Mike Reta (Mikey Knucks Models)
Feb 16, 2026
5.0
It was a great Pizza spot, but just a pizza spot. Excellent food and service
JC
Jen Ciolino
Feb 15, 2026
5.0
Another reviewer called it “ordinary.” That’s what it’s so great! We got it fast and late delivered to our hotel. We’re from Chicago but moved away in 2014. We live in Cincinnati, and late night “ordinary” is better at Pazza than the BEST pizza in Cincinnati. Would recommend!
KH
kenneth houston
Feb 14, 2026
5.0
Truly some of the best food you will have in Chicago. Excellent customer service from the employees and cooks and a great atmosphere overall. I try to come here anytime I’m in the area for a slice of pizza. The wings are top tier delicious too!
LN
Lily Nielsen
Feb 4, 2026
5.0
so yummy, easy, and inexpensive! i come here all the time!
GR
G Reta
Jan 23, 2026
5.0
Pizza (one cheese and one meat) and jalapeno poppers were delicious! The poppers are possibly made in-house???!!! Ordered delivery on restaurant website and the service was great. The food arrived earlier than expected (still hot).