The sign lights up, “Nancy’s Pizza” as you climb out of your car and head for the door of Chicago’s historic pizza place. The walls full of black and white photos of ages past welcome you back as you order your regular: a Nancy’s Original Stuffed Pizza. You sit, and take your first bite,
oozy gooey cheesy goodness, and you can’t help but smile. You can almost hear the decades-old conversations and laughs shared by your friends and those who have passed through Chicago's iconic pizzeria. When you leave, you nod at the iconic "Get Stuffed" neon sign, in front of which many pictures were, and have yet to be, taken. It feels as if no time has passed at all. Dine in or order out at Nancy’s Pizza in West Loop, Chicago—where memories are made.
Customers praised the delicious deep dish and thin crust pizzas, highlighting the homemade flavors and quality ingredients.
Service
Many reviews commended the friendly and attentive staff, with specific mentions of exceptional service from individual servers.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's warm and inviting atmosphere was frequently noted, making it a comfortable spot for dining.
Takeout Experience
While many enjoyed the takeout, some customers reported issues with order timing and food temperature.
Value
Some customers felt the prices were high for the portion sizes, particularly for takeout orders.
CC
Carlisle Cain
1 day ago
5.0
Landed in Chicago for a work trip. Wanted to try some real Chicago style pizza. And man was this it! Cozy vibe to the place and top natch service! Ill have to come back next time im in Chicago .
ES
Emilee Sorensen
3 days ago
5.0
Service was great, food was amazing! The deep dish pizza and breadsticks were so good. Highly recommend!
GZ
Gamer-Chick Zombie
5 days ago
5.0
It's a charming restaurant that I've been going to with my family and friends, since I was a kid. The owners and staff are personable and very kind. The food is delicious, but my favorite is their famous stuffed pizza.
MN
Mariah Kamara (Naomi)
Jan 4, 2026
5.0
Nancy’s Pizza has never disappointed me and I have been getting their pizza for years. The other night I was completely baked and my munchies were in full effect. I couldn’t decide whether to wait for delivery like a responsible adult or just grab my pizza and go. I live just a few blocks away so I went with pick-up and ordered a super thin 12" pizza with Italian sausage and mushrooms to enjoy myself and share a little with my dog Winston.
Picking up the pizza was smooth as always. The staff was friendly and welcoming and the restaurant is always clean and organized. Every single time I have picked up an order it has been ready exactly when they said it would be which makes life so much easier.
Taking the pizza home was the best part. Every bite was amazing. The crust, the toppings, and the balance of flavors were perfect. Eating it baked at home felt like pure bliss. Honestly Nancy’s is one of the best pizza spots in Chicago and I don’t see that changing anytime soon.
Nancy’s I will absolutely be back. You have a loyal fan in me and Winston is already plotting the next slice.
PJ
Prarit Julka
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
Their pizzas are awesome! We’ve always ordered the thin crust and have tried different toppings, it’s always been consistently good.
How can I contact Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop for comments or inquiries?
You can contact Nancy's Pizza via email at comments@nancyspizza.com or call them at +1 312-733-9920.
Are there any notable places to visit near Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop?
Nearby notable places include Lola's Restaurant & Bar for additional dining options and La Sardine, a French restaurant, providing a variety of eateries around.
What nearby businesses can help with banking or financial services when visiting Nancy's Pizza?
Visitors can find Byline Bank nearby for banking and professional services, as well as Compass Mortgage, Inc. for mortgage brokerage needs.
What nearby spots can I visit if I have pets and plan to dine at Nancy's Pizza?
West Loop Wags, a nearby veterinarian, pet services, and dog walking facility, is close by if you need any pet care while enjoying your meal.