The banana pudding is highly praised, with many customers calling it the best they've ever had, though some noted issues with the ratio of ingredients.
Customer Service
The staff is frequently described as friendly and helpful, contributing positively to the overall experience.
Product Quality
While many desserts are enjoyed, there are mixed reviews on the quality of cupcakes and other baked goods, with some customers finding them underwhelming.
Cleanliness
Several reviews mention cleanliness issues within the bakery, indicating a need for improvement in this area.
Pricing
Customers express concerns about the high prices relative to portion sizes and quality, suggesting that some items may not provide good value.
JJ
Jin Yeah Jiang
6 days ago
5.0
The Hummingbird Cake was moist, and the cream cheese frosting on it was delicious! Plenty of pecans and pineapple. It was the best I've had in a long time.
My girls, who got cheesecake got cheesecake, loved that. My daughter loves her banana pudding.
Everyone was so welcoming and courteous, they made our stay a pleasure.
NH
Neil Harris
Dec 31, 2025
2.0
I'm from the UK, so we don't have banana pudding. I've had the banana pudding from here before and it was really nice. I bought some today 31/12/25, and it wasn't good I'm sad to say. It was primarily sponge, little banana and a rim of cream around the top. Very dry. Hopefully just a one off.
LT
Louis Titze
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
I got the banana pudding and the banana pudding cookie and wow I was flashed. Delicious really delicious. If you like the real banana taste and no artificial taste you are going to love it.
RR
Ric
Dec 24, 2025
5.0
Had such a lovely experience at Magnolia. Even though it was busy and crowded, the lady working ( forgot to ask her name) there had incredible warmth and positive energy. She made everyone feel welcome despite the holiday rush.
Honestly, God bless her for working during the holiday season and still taking the time to make others feel valued. Little moments like this truly make someone’s day. Will definitely be back.
KS
Kevin Solgat
Dec 24, 2025
2.0
Had their famous banana pudding. Ordered a large. Only had 1 super small peice of banana in it. Nothing like their website pictures. Super sweet like eating pure frosting thats whipped with a lot of vanilla wafers. Disappointed that it lacked bananas! I also ordered the Carmel nut cheese cake. Now that cheese cake was amazing!!! I would definitely order the cheesecake again!