The banana pudding is highly praised for its flavor and texture, with many customers calling it a must-try.
Customer Service
The staff is frequently described as friendly and welcoming, contributing positively to the overall experience.
Cleanliness
Several reviews mention cleanliness issues, with some customers noting that the bakery appeared dirty or poorly maintained.
Pricing
Many customers feel that the prices are high for the portion sizes and quality, leading to mixed feelings about value.
Product Consistency
While many enjoy the banana pudding, there are complaints about inconsistency in quality and freshness across different visits.
BH
Barbie H
6 days ago
5.0
Yum yum yummy!!! I can’t wait to go back a get more! I tried the Hazelnut, Apple Crisp, regular & cookies and cream banana puddings and all so delicious!! The hazelnut had chocolate chip pieces and could most definitely do without that. Of those weren’t in the pudding I would love it down!! The cookies and cream and apple crisp were so so delicious. The flavor was so good. I love making banana pudding and will be trying new add ins when I make it. However, I will be going here to get some when I don’t feel like making it!! Can’t wait to go back!
HI
hamzah ibrahim
Nov 14, 2025
3.0
Classic banana pudding — it’s delicious
But a quick request to whoever makes it: please reduce the amount of sugar a little so the sweetness is more balanced and not overly sweet.”
HS
Hayley So
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
This pudding was out of this world. I’m not even a big fan of banana but the combination of cream and vanilla cake just blends wonderfully.
A delightful snack after watching Broadway.
KM
Keenon Morris
Nov 10, 2025
3.0
This place was jam packed with people waiting on this banana pudding. This place is known for that. So I decided to give it a try. Ok it was ok not some of the best of I. Was more on the thick side and I'm use to that good creamy smooth texture. I did have a brownie to and it was the same. Now some people may like it and some my not I just giving you my own personal review.
HH
Hagz
Oct 29, 2025
5.0
The banana pudding is just amazing. Something | guarantee that you will crave after your first visit! ( My wife and I are literally talking about our craving as we speak.) The banana pudding is cold, fresh, and fluffy. Each bite is full of flavor and you get a bite of the banana, vanilla wafers, and pudding in every spoonful. We have gone multiple times and each experience was great. They are very consistent with their products which makes this even better. My wife also got the carrot cake banana pudding and we enjoyed that as well. I will say that the carrot pudding is a little more on the sweeter side but still delicious. Haven't tried any of the baked goods but do plan on doing so on the next visit cause everything looks so good! 100% recommend!