Italian Fiesta Pizzeria

3.7
1812 reviews
gallery picture

About

Pizza Restaurant
Italian Fiesta Pizzeria is your top spot for Italian pickup in Chicago, IL, serving up authentic Italian cuisine made from traditional family recipes. From our famous thin-crust pizzas to hearty pasta dishes, sandwiches, shrimp, and chicken entrees, every meal is crafted with quality ingredients and bold flavors. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, our cozy, welcoming atmosphere and quick service make us a local favorite. Perfect for a casual night or a family feast, our menu brings a true taste of Italy to the heart of Chicago. Place your order today and experience authentic Italian flavor on the go.

Location

Italian Fiesta Pizzeria
1919 East 71st Street, Chicago, IL
60649, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.7
1,812 reviews
5 stars
869
4 stars
344
3 stars
184
2 stars
96
1 star
319

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Pizza Quality

Customers frequently praised the pizza for being delicious and authentic, though some reported inconsistencies in quality and preparation.

Customer Service

There were numerous complaints about poor customer service, including rudeness and lack of attention to orders.

Delivery Issues

Many customers experienced long wait times for delivery and issues with incorrect orders.

Atmosphere

The lack of a dining area was noted, with some customers expressing disappointment over the takeout-only setup.
  • TT
    Tammy
    1 day ago
    5.0
    How pizza should look and taste my family devoured both pizzas in minutes. Italian fiesta never disappoints. I’m ashamed to say I been taking chances and wasting money with other pizza places but not anymore
  • DR
    Dinah Redmond
    2 days ago
    1.0
    I could NOT believe how awful this pizza was! I order a large thin crust cheese and sausage pizza yesterday for $30 which is the typical price for that size pizza, however the crust taste like stale crackers and very little cheese. My guest were so disappointed! You know pizza is bad when you have over half the box left after your guest leave and no wanted to take any home. So disappointed I will NOT be returning to this establishment! The pizza DID NOT look like the pictures!
  • CH
    C. Han
    4 days ago
    5.0
    Young lady who took my phone order was very polite and pick-up went smoothly. Pizza was very tasty.
  • BR
    Behati Rose
    5 days ago
    1.0
    You know your in for a bumpy ride when you called the call center and they’re the ignorant one highly unprofessional the chick answering the phone blocked me and we didn’t have one confrontation she’s Very petty. They need multiple people to call the Better Business Bureau in on them
  • AR
    Andre Robinson
    Jan 4, 2026
    3.0
    I only ate there because my coworker had a slice. I've had better and probably won't waste my time or money again.

Frequently Asked Questions About Italian Fiesta Pizzeria

What type of cuisine does Italian Fiesta Pizzeria specialize in?

Italian Fiesta Pizzeria specializes in authentic Italian cuisine made from traditional family recipes, including thin-crust pizzas, pasta dishes, sandwiches, shrimp, and chicken entrees.

Where is Italian Fiesta Pizzeria located?

Italian Fiesta Pizzeria is located at 1919 East 71st Street, Chicago, IL 60649, USA.