Sarah’s Bagel Cafe 2

Reviews

• KN

  Kristie Nash

  Apr 10, 2026
  5.0
  Since hearing about Sarah’s place we order from here a lot because the food is amazing and the price is right.
• MS

  Matt Sivley

  Apr 4, 2026
  1.0
  I have eaten here a few times and really liked it. My go to has always been the #26 Lox Bagel. I ordered one to go. Got back to work. Took a bite and found the Lox was rancid. I inspected the Lox and found it slimy and stanky. I felt sick all day from eating the one bite. I called the store and told them they need to inspect the Lox and told them what happened. I did get an apology from staff. If u order from here inspect the sandwich before you eat.
• SL

  Shazz Love

  Mar 29, 2026
  1.0
  I came in for the first time and order a turkey sandwich. It wasn’t a long wait, but went to look for a table. There was only 2 tables occupied. But every table was dirty with bread crumbs. I order a turkey sandwich forgot the exact name. When I got it presentation was bad. I opened my sandwich and half of it didn’t have avocado, bacon or onion. I figured ok it happens probably slide to the other half. Nope the other half had a tiny amount of avocado and onions. This sandwich had a strong taste of mayo. Never coming back, I had a better experiences at the 12th street location.
• RP

  Richard Perkins

  Mar 26, 2026
  5.0
  Had a large online order for pickup. Order was completed and ready for pickup on time.
• RL

  Roberta Lopez

  Mar 22, 2026
  5.0
  Love Sarah’s breakfast sandwiches! Will keep coming back.