About
Pizza Restaurant
Although we first opened our doors in 1980, our current owners Ed and Christine bought the restaurant in 1987 after managing it for the first seven years of Maxie's being in Kimberly. We've been providing freshly cooked meals and award-winning customer service ever since. Our team has served generations of patrons for decades. No matter if you're a first-time or repeat customer, you'll be back for more food soon.
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.4
317 reviews
5 stars
219
4 stars
49
3 stars
19
2 stars
13
1 star
17
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Mixed reviews on food quality; while some praised the pizza and salad bar, others criticized the pasta dishes and undercooked pizzas.
Service
Service quality varied; some customers reported friendly staff, while others experienced rudeness and long wait times.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere received criticism for being gloomy and in need of updates, though some found it quaint.
Pricing
Prices were considered high by some customers, especially given the inconsistent food quality.
Customer Loyalty
Many long-time customers expressed loyalty to the brand, reminiscing about its previous incarnation as Maxie's.
- CRCassandra Ruby6 days ago5.0FANTASTIC ravioli!!!!!
- PPPatienceOct 17, 20251.0The cashier was nice, but the atmosphere was gloomy, like a hospital. We ordered 2 spaghetti, 1 alfredo, and a salad bar and garlic bread. Our food cost about 60 dollars.The salad bar was really good but everything else was terrible. The bread sticks were gross, and the garlic bread was topped with garlic and oil, and wasn't good at all. The spaghetti sauce looked like it came out of a can or was frozen, it was chunky and didn't taste good. The 16 dollar alfredo with shrimp was oily and had too much garlic in it. It had cheap popcorn shrimp in it. Food was so bad and expensive that I couldn't even force myself to eat it because I started to feel sick. There are plenty of other places that you can go to get better food for the same price.
- LDLanny “goose1127” DentonSep 23, 20255.0We have went here for years and really enjoy their food they got good prices and good food it's worth the drive
- GGGoogle GoogleSep 14, 20251.0Closed at random times, unreliable business.
- GRG RAThbunAug 13, 20254.0Like everything else in life nowadays the food quality is just not quite what it used to be but still good. Service was real good clean and quiet place to have a lunch
Frequently Asked Questions About Monterey Jack's
What are the operating hours of Monterey Jack's?
Monterey Jack's is open Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 8:30 PM, and Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM. It is closed on Sundays.
What types of cuisine does Monterey Jack's specialize in?
Monterey Jack's specializes in pizza, pastas, salads, fingersteaks, chicken tenders, and cheeseburgers.
What payment methods can I use at Monterey Jack's?
You can pay using American Express, Apple Pay, Check, Discover, MasterCard, Traveler's Check, and Visa at Monterey Jack's.
Does Monterey Jack's offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, Monterey Jack's offers in-store pickup, curbside pickup, delivery, same-day delivery, and no-contact delivery options.
Where is Monterey Jack's located?
Monterey Jack's is located at 626 Main Street North, Kimberly, ID 83341, United States.
What is the history of Monterey Jack's restaurant?
Monterey Jack's first opened in 1980. The current owners, Ed and Christine, have been managing the restaurant since 1987 after initially managing it for seven years. The restaurant has served freshly cooked meals and award-winning customer service for generations.
Are there any popular nearby pizza restaurants to Monterey Jack's?
Yes, Maxie's Pizza & Pasta is a nearby pizza restaurant where customers might also enjoy authentic pizza and pasta when visiting the area.
What other services are near Monterey Jack's that customers might find useful?
Nearby, you can find automotive services like Twin Falls Trailer Rental and U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer, perfect for truck or trailer rental needs before or after your meal at Monterey Jack's.
Are there places to shop or enjoy other activities near Monterey Jack's?
Yes, there are various nearby places including Lazy H Soda Barn for beverages, Jessie’s Ceramic Shoppe for arts and crafts, and Extreme Dance studio for active life and school activities.
Can I find professional services nearby Monterey Jack's?
Yes, nearby professional services include Jojo Marie Photography for event photography and Ying’s Luscious Lips for beauty salon services.