Sarah's Bagel Cafe Idaho

Reviews

• EE

  EndOfDays

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Delicious and affordable
• GL

  Glen Lexa

  5 days ago
  5.0
  First time at Sarah’s Bagels downtown today. Had the strawberry banana smoothie and man… that thing was the bomb. Totally hit the spot this afternoon. I usually go to the South Nampa spot and love it down there, so I had to check this one out. Same great food. Same good vibe. Yep… I’ll be back. Glen StandOut Online Reviews
• KH

  Katarina Hockema

  6 days ago
  3.0
  After a customer service experience from my last visit wherein I was not acknowledged nor allowed to get my prepared online order despite it being paid/ready and within sight for several minutes, I gave Sarah's one more go. I ordered online at 11:35a for a 12:15p pickup for a salami bagel. I arrived on time, but my order was not prepared. I stood in the pickup area and was not acknowledged by any staff for several minutes (again) as they continued to take and prepare walk in orders. Eventually, I was able to confirm my order with staff who proceeded to make it then and there, showing that it was not prepared as an online order despite generous advance notice and prepayment. The bagel itself was good, but the lack of prioritization for the online service option and disrespect of customer time is a concern and completely defeats the point of ordering ahead. Thankfully, I have a long enough lunch to where this is not a major inconvenience, but I know that's not the case for those with a tighter timeframe who can't afford to waste a third of their break waiting to get something they should already have received. I will not be returning.
• NW

  Nathan Whitley

  Feb 3, 2026
  5.0
  I really like this place. For a long time I would get the croissant sandwich with sausage egg and cheese. It was absolutely perfect. Now lately I’ve been getting an egg and cheese bagel. It is almost perfect. It could use a pinch of salt, but I still really like it- and it costs less than 5 dollars, so in a way it’s perfect.
• CF

  Courtney Flowers

  Dec 18, 2025
  4.0
  They were very slow in the morning. Now fast service at all. I came back later in the afternoon and was willing to wait. Yummy bagels, boba wasn't 10/10 at this location