Castaway Cafe

Reviews

• SB

  Sandra Brayer

  1 day ago
  5.0
  No wait to get seated on their patio. Great food and drinks! I highly recommend! Our server Jamie P. was great!
• JJ

  Jolo

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Fast service,eggs Benedicts were cooked to perfection and the plain pancake was good too,our waitress was some awesome and so happy
• AO

  Alicia Ostenson

  Feb 19, 2026
  5.0
  Great place tucked away! Salads and views amazing! We were staying next door and came here multiple times!
• KS

  Ken Smithers

  Feb 14, 2026
  5.0
  My fiance and visited the castaway Cafe back in 2010 . It was an amazing experience. Wayne and Abba were excellent bartenders. We came back 2 years later and they both remembered our names. We are now married and in maui for 2xweeks. Hope to go back on Sunday the 15th of Feb. Can't wait to be there.
• GG

  Gentry

  Feb 8, 2026
  5.0
  On a recent trip to Maui, we stayed at the Kaanapali Villas. For this review, I want to talk about the on site restaurant,Castaway Cafe. After a few hours on the beach, we were heading back to our condo when tantalizing smells emanating from the open air dining area stopped us in our tracks. As we approached the hostess stand, we were told that since it was such a cool, cloudy day, the head chef decided to create a creamy chicken soup utilizing some odds and ends around their kitchen. I asked if it was the soup we were smelling and they said that it was and brought us a sample. Creamy, hearty, flavorful with big chunks of chicken & elbow macaroni, we ordered the biggest bowl they had! In addition to soup, our party of 5 partook of the fish & chips, fish tacos, kids mac n cheese & of course I had the nachos. These were not just any nachos, the pork was uniquely seasoned with a delicate sauce, the beans hearty & flavorful, with crisp homemade chips, pico, cheese sauce and guac. The fish n chips were well cooked, lightly seasoned & came with a fun basket of french fries while the mahi mahi tacos were served with cilantro lime crema, pico and a side of chips n salsa. The Castaway has a seated, full bar, indoor & outdoor table seating, lovely views of the ocean and excellent service. They also had live music from local performers the night we were there. We interacted with several staff members, all of whom were professional, kind and friendly. We highly recommend the Castaway Cafe if you are looking for a family friendly, delicious meal while visiting Kaanapali Villas.

Frequently Asked Questions About Castaway Cafe