Central City Tavern - Sugar Hill

Reviews

• CQ

  Chuck Quarles

  4 days ago
  3.0
  Well, it’s McDonalds food, so it will be consistent with other McDonalds. However, this is a new restaurant that just opened in the last few months, but it is still terribly terribly slow in the drive thru. Not sure if they are understaffed or what. At least the drive thru people were very nice and apologetic.
• BB

  BiggTubbsInnit

  5 days ago
  2.0
  Awful food. Sweet servers but wicked slow at 4 on a Tuesday.
• JL

  Josh L.

  6 days ago
  1.0
  !!! WOMEN BEWARE !!! Last night, I stopped by to get some work done and grab some food. As I was leaving, I witnessed a man holding a woman in a chokehold. I approached the man and asked him to stop choking her. To make a long story short: the bartender intervened and told me they were "just playing" and that it was okay. I am not sure in what world it is acceptable to put a woman in a chokehold, but that was his position. I was then asked to leave the property. I never raised my voice or threatened anyone; I brought awareness to the situation calmly and professionally. This establishment does not take its customers' safety seriously. There were only 3–4 staff members on duty, and they seemed focused on closing early while neglecting what was happening to the people they were serving. Women: if you go here, do not go alone. The staff has made it clear that they will not step up for you, and if a bystander tries to help, the staff will ask that person to leave. "Shady" is not even the word for how this company allows its employees to manage the business. Lastly, when I called today, I was told the owner was at their Alpharetta location. When I spoke to the owner in Alpharetta, he made it clear he does not own the Sugar Hill location and that it’s owned by someone else. I hope the actual owner of the Sugar Hill location see this review and makes adjustments immediately to ensure guest safety. They need to take action now and make safety their #1 priority before something avoidable happens. Definitely lost my family and friends business that live in the area. ——— Updating this review from the response left from the business. I appreciate the response to my review and hope that what you stated happens. My question is you’re “investigating”what happened but yet it’s been 2 days since I contacted your business. I have not received a return call or acknowledgment from your company other than your review response to the public. The owner of Alpharetta doesn’t even own that location but yet he took my call the same day. Took his time to discuss the situation and has passed my info to the actual location this review is about. Again. I hope for the best but how can you say you want to earn my business back from a Google review but not take the initiative to contact me directly as well ? Seems to me this is a general response to my public experience at your business more so than actually taking action in regard to what is taking place at your establishment. It’s disappointing to see an awesome location treated like a hobby than a real business.
• EB

  Emily Bradley

  Mar 1, 2026
  3.0
  We enjoy coming here because it’s close and we like the menu. We’ve had a few service experiences that were challenging but keep showing up to give business to a local spot. Tonight we came on a Sunday and were excited to see half price apps and Tropicala beer on Sunday evenings. We ordered 3 apps, 2 tropicalas and several other things. When the bill arrived, they had only discounted the beer. My husband asked and was told “oh the apps are only half price for industry night.” Yet he couldn’t explain what that meant and that’s certainly not listed on the menu. It truly felt like bait and switch (which is illegal so I hope that’s not the case). Not sure how owns or manages this spot, but their business advertisements and practices need revised. Service is hit or miss. Waitress tonight was kind! Sometimes they seem bothered or hungover….
• HH

  Hmbleman13

  Feb 28, 2026
  5.0
  Both the burgers and drinks were wonderful. Seb was an amazing server who checked on us frequently.