New York Butcher Shoppe

Reviews

• LW

  Lucy Wickstead

  1 day ago
  5.0
  This shop always has supreme meats but today I tried their white chicken lasagna. It was phenomenal. The staff is always so helpful and friendly. When I moved to atlanta, my son said I had to go here. Don't forget to pick up a brownie while you're there. They are addictive
• AN

  Amihai Nagar

  3 days ago
  4.0
  Good steak good customer service!
• JJ

  John

  Apr 12, 2026
  1.0
  They have no clue what they’re talking about. I asked where all their meat was sourced from none of the Employees knew. I asked if the beef was grass fed and they said I don’t know what the cow is fed. How clueless can a shop be
• SZ

  Samantha Zimmermann

  Apr 9, 2026
  5.0
  When I walk in here I immediately feel looked out for, and taken care of. I've seen the same two people so far when grabbing my tenderloin for the month, both times they greeted me with hospitality you don't seem to find anywhere else in Atlanta. Not to mention the prime tenderloin made for INSANELY good filet mignon. Very tender and juicy. The lady working the first time also gave me a huge brownie for being my first time that I ate slowly with my partner over the course of 2 days lol(one of the best brownies I've had too). Second time I come in they're giving me a discount just because. 10/10 energy from staff/good vibes and it's been 10/10 meats, sauces and other things you would get from a butcher shop. Definitely worth driving out of my way for.
• MC

  Mike Chapman

  Feb 19, 2026
  5.0
  I just went in this place after years of driving by. All I can say is WOW!!. The selection of true prime beef is amazing. I initially went in a month ago just to check the place out. The staff was super friendly and helpful. Today I was ready to purchase. They went above and beyond to get me two beautiful New York Strips within my budget. They have a customer for life in me. Don't waste your time at Grocery stores or Farmers markets who claim to have prime beef. Come to the New York Butcher Shoppe and get the real deal!!