Tommy's Pizza and Pasta

Reviews

• JC

  Jennifer Castle

  Apr 19, 2026
  3.0
  No complaints about the food, its excellent. My issue was customer relations. Young lady at register was nice, the rest of the staff is a bit gruff. My to-go order was not ready when I arrived, I was informed, because my instructions were unclear. I ordered 30 minutes ahead. I did receive a text informing me the order was ready. I was never contacted about the misunderstanding because "there was no time to call". I was then made to feel like the delay was my fault because the kitchen did not understand how to make a half and half pizza with extra cheese. After, the pizza was left on top of the oven and my husband was repeatedly told it was not ready as he stood and waited (I did not want to go back in). Again, the food is very good but, when you're paying $33 for one large pizza, customer service should be just as good as the food.
• AF

  Andrew Fenstermacher

  Apr 17, 2026
  5.0
  Ordered a pepperoni a little over and it was perfect. Best pizza in the area hands down
• TM

  Tricia Martin

  Apr 4, 2026
  5.0
  Grabbed a few pies for dinner. Friends visiting us from NJ. They loved it! Your cauliflower pizza is the best I’ve had!!
• CG

  Christina G

  Apr 1, 2026
  5.0
  The food was delicious, and our order was ready when we arrived. The app made the whole ordering process quick and hassle free. We got great value for our money, and everyone really enjoyed the food.
• MW

  Marena White-Hogg

  Mar 28, 2026
  3.0
  Everything is a generous portion... but omg the flavor lacks. There's peas (?) in my pasta a la vodka?? The meatballs were enormous and delicious. I have yet to try the cheese sticks and marinara and can update when I do. But with the pasta being my main drive to try a Pizza and Pasta place... I am actually disappointed. There's no way to save the pasta either: it's watery (not saucy) and really only tastes of peas... the weirdest penne a la vodka I've ever had. Like, I caught myself saying "there's no fixing this..." Def save your money and wait to get pasta elsewhere.