Many customers praised the friendly and attentive service, highlighting specific staff members for their exceptional service.
Food Quality
The pizza and sandwiches received high marks for quality and flavor, with many customers calling it the best they've had in the area.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as cozy and welcoming, with a pleasant atmosphere for dining and social events.
Inconsistency
Some reviews noted issues with food preparation, such as overcooked pizza and incorrect orders, indicating a need for consistency.
Value
Customers appreciated the reasonable prices for the quality of food, especially during special promotions like 50-cent wings.
SK
Sabrina Keigley
Nov 16, 2025
5.0
Stopped here from out of town, could not say enough wonderful things about this place!ππ»ππ»ππ» We were created as soon as we came in the door and seated. Our server was absolutely phenomenal it was super attentive, kind, and efficient! Tough combo to beat! I hate to say I actually forget her name even after making an appointment to try to remember! In case it helps management to give her kudos, we went on November 6th in the evening β₯οΈπ
We got the specialty pizza that was hot honey and added pepperoni, ABSOLUTELY SCRUMPTIOUS!!!!
Just the right amount of toppings, sauce, and cheese! We will definitely find our way back when we visit next time! β₯οΈπ
BB
Bryan Bear
Nov 15, 2025
5.0
Food was hot and ready on time for our pick up.
GG
Glasskey10
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
Terrific pizza, worth the extra miles we have to drive to get there. You can get pizza anywhere, but Pizza 54 has The Good Pizza that we go past the other pizza places to get to.
KF
K F
Nov 6, 2025
5.0
Amazing food!! Try the pizza of the week, it doesnβt disappoint. Hopefully it makes its way to the menu soon.
BB
Britania
Nov 1, 2025
5.0
Loved this little gem! Food was plentiful with a cozy atmosphere! Tyler, our server, was THE BEST!!